WesleyanHeritage Library Search
Menu
1 Samuel · 22 verses

1 Samuel 24

Read slowly. Let the words lead you to Christ.

Chapter introductions

John Wesley

CHAPTER 24.

Saul pursues David to Engedi, ver. 1, 2. David cuts off his skirt, ver. 3-7. He reasons with Saul, ver. 8-15. Saul owns his fault, and returns home, ver. 16-22

Adam Clarke

CHAPTER 24

Saul is informed that David is at En-gedi, and goes to seek him with three thousand men, 1, 2. He goes into a cave to repose, where David and his men lay hid; who, observing this, exhort David to take away his life: David refuses, and contents himself with privily cutting off Saul’s skirt, 3-7. When Saul departed, not knowing what was done, David called after him; showed him that his life had been in his power; expostulates strongly with him; and appeals to God, the Judge of his innocence, 8-15. Saul confesses David’s uprightness, acknowledges his obligation to him for sparing his life; and causes him to swear that, when he should come to the kingdom, he would not destroy his seed, 17-21. Saul returns home, and David and his men stay in the hold, 22. NOTES ON CHAP. 24

Joseph Benson

CHAPTER 24.

A.M. 2943. — B.C. 1061.

Saul pursues David to Engedi, 1, 2. David cuts off his skirt, 3-7. He reasons with Saul, 8-15. Saul owns his fault, and returns home, 16-22. NOTES ON CHAPTER 24.

Joseph Sutcliffe

CHAPTER 24.

Daniel Whedon

CHAPTER 24.

1

And it came to pass, when Saul was returned from following the Philistines, that it was told him, saying, Behold, David is in the wilderness of Engedi.

Adam Clarke on 1 Samuel 24:1
Clarke's Commentary · source PDF p. 143

Verse 1. Saul was returned] It is very probable that it was only a small marauding party that had made an excursion in the Israelitish borders, and this invasion was soon suppressed.

Joseph Sutcliffe on 1 Samuel 24:1
Joseph Sutcliffe's Commentary · source PDF p. 752

Verse 1. En-gedi was adjacent to the dead sea. Strabo, speaking of the caverns in Syria and Iturea, says, there is one which will hold four thousand men. Lib. 16.

Daniel Whedon on 1 Samuel 24:1–22
Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testament · source PDF p. 560

DAVID AND SAUL IN THE WILDERNESS OF EN-GEDI, 1-22.

1. When Saul was returned from following the Philistines — This was another of those bitter contests with that enemy against whom Saul was obliged to carry on war all his days, (1 Samuel 14:52;) but how long this war with the Philistines lasted, and of its relative importance, we are not informed. En-gedi — The modern Ain-Jidy, situated about the middle of the western coast of the Dead Sea. Its name was transferred from a fountain near the sea to the whole neighbouring wilderness on the west, which is full of deep ravines, rocky ridges and dark caverns.

2

Then Saul took three thousand chosen men out of all Israel, and went to seek David and his men upon the rocks of the wild goats.

John Wesley on 1 Samuel 24:2
John Wesley's Explanatory Notes · source PDF p. 70

V. 2. Rocks-Which the wild goats used to delight in and climb over. These very rocks are exceeding steep, and full of precipices, and dangerous to travellers, as an eye-witness hath left upon record. And yet Saul was so transported with rage, as to venture himself and his army here, that he might take David, who, as he thought, would judge himself safe, and therefore be secure in such inaccessible places.

Adam Clarke on 1 Samuel 24:2
Clarke's Commentary · source PDF p. 143

Editorial note: Source collation note — paragraph 1: “wild goats.] the original (צורי היעלים tsurey haiyeelim) is variously”; “name; for out of צרוי היעלים tsurey haiyeelim, they make”. source PDF page 143: “wild goats. The original היעלים צורי tsurey haiyeelim is variously”; “name; for out of היעלים צרוי tsurey haiyeelim they make”. Compared with CLA_1SA.PDF PDF p. 143. The source-font or layout comparison does not securely establish every letter, mark or local sequence in these passages. The flagged language readings or layout are retained; the original source pages should be consulted for these specific readings. Additional-source investigation: an automated comparison of surrounding English text located possible corresponding passages in OCR from separately digitized printed volumes. The linked scan pages are research locators; their images have not been collated for this note's flagged readings. OCR agreement does not verify Greek or Hebrew letters, diacritics, word order, or table layout. The flagged readings or layout remain uncertain. CLA_1SA.PDF, PDF page 143; Additional printed-scan page locator (OCR context only; flagged reading unverified).

Verse 2. Rocks of the wild goats.] The original (צורי היעלים tsurey haiyeelim) is variously understood. The VULGATE makes a paraphrase: Super abruptissimas petras quæ solis ibicibus perviæ sunt; “On the most precipitous rocks over which the ibexes alone can travel.” The TARGUM: the caverns of the rocks. The SEPTUAGINT make the original a proper name; for out of צרוי היעלים tsurey haiyeelim, they make σαδδαιεμ Saddaiem, and in some copies αειαμειν Aeiamein, which are evidently corruptions of the Hebrew.

Joseph Benson on 1 Samuel 24:2
Joseph Benson's Commentary · source PDF p. 267

Verse 2. Upon the rocks of the wild goats — Which the wild goats used to delight in and climb over. These same rocks are exceeding steep, and full of precipices, and dangerous to travellers, as an eye-witness hath left upon record. And yet Saul was so transported with rage as to venture himself and his army here, that he might take David, who, as he thought, would judge himself safe, and therefore be secure in such inaccessible places.

Daniel Whedon on 1 Samuel 24:2
Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testament · source PDF p. 560

2. The rocks of the wild goats — Dr. Robinson thus speaks of his travels in this region: “As we now came in view of the ravine of the Wady Ghar a mountain goat started up and bounded along the face of the rocks on the opposite side. Indeed, we were now in the wilderness of En-gedi, where David and his men lived among ‘the rocks of the wild goats,’ and where the former cut off the skirts of Saul’s robe in a cave. The whole scene is drawn to the life. On all sides the country is full of caverns, which might then serve as lurking places for David and his men, as they do for outlaws at the present day.”

3

And he came to the sheepcotes by the way, where was a cave; and Saul went in to cover his feet: and David and his men remained in the sides of the cave.

John Wesley on 1 Samuel 24:3
John Wesley's Explanatory Notes · source PDF p. 70

V. 3. Went in-To sleep there: Saul being a military man, used to sleep with his soldiers upon the ground. And it is not improbable, that being weary with his eager and almost incessant pursuit, first of David, then of the Philistines, and now of David again, he both needed and desired some sleep, God also disposing him thereto, that David might have this eminent occasion to demonstrate his integrity to Saul, and to all Israel. Of the cave-For that there were vast caves in those parts is affirmed, not only by Josephus, but also by Heathen authors; Strabo writes of one which could receive four thousand men.

Adam Clarke on 1 Samuel 24:3
Clarke's Commentary · source PDF p. 143

Editorial note: Source collation note — source PDF page 143: “containing four thousand men ων εν και τετρακισχιλιους ανθρωπους δεξασθαι δυναμενον lib. xvi. p. 1096. (source keys requiring collation: Jwn)”. Compared with CLA_1SA.PDF PDF p. 143. The source-font or layout comparison does not securely establish every letter, mark or local sequence in these passages. The flagged language readings or layout are retained; the original source pages should be consulted for these specific readings. Additional-source investigation: the available separately digitized printed volumes were searched, but the corresponding passage was not securely located. The flagged readings or layout remain uncertain; this search provides no basis for reconstructing or silently normalizing them. CLA_1SA.PDF, PDF page 143.

Verse 3. The sheep-cotes] Caves in the rocks, in which it is common, even to the present time, for shepherds and their flocks to lodge. According to Strabo there are caverns in Syria, one of which is capable of containing four thousand men: ων εν και τετρακισχιλιους ανθρωπους

δεξασθαι δυναμενον; lib. xvi. p. 1096. Edit. 1707.

Saul went in to cover his feet] Perhaps this phrase signifies exactly what the Vulgate has rendered it, ut purparet ventrem. The Septuagint, the Targum, and the Arabic understand it in the same way. It is likely that, when he had performed this act of necessity, he lay down to repose himself, and it was while he was asleep that David cut off the skirt of his robe. It is strange that Saul was not aware that there might be men lying in wait in such a place; and the rabbins have invented a most curious conceit to account for Saul’s security: “God, foreseeing that Saul would come to this cave, caused a spider to weave her web over the mouth of it, which, when Saul perceived, he took for granted that no person had lately been there, and consequently he entered it without suspicion.” This may be literally true; and we know that even a spider in the hand of God may be the instrument of a great salvation. This is a Jewish tradition, and one of the most elegant and instructive in their whole collection. David and his men remained in the sides of the cave.] This is no hyperbole; we have not only the authority of Strabo as above mentioned, but we have the authority of the most accurate travellers, to attest the fact of the vast capacity of caves in the East.

Dr. Pococke observes: “Beyond the valley (of Tekoa) there is a very large grotto, which the Arabs call El Maamah, a hiding place; the high rocks on each side of the valley are almost perpendicular, and the way to the grotto is by a terrace formed in the rock, which is very narrow. There are two entrances into it; we went by the farthest, which leads by a narrow passage into a large grotto, the rock being supported by great natural pillars; the top of it rises in several parts like domes; the grotto is perfectly dry. There is a tradition that the people of the country, to the number of thirty thousand, retired into this grotto to avoid a bad air. This place is so strong that one would imagine it to be one of the strong holds of En-gedi, to which David and his men fled from Saul; and possibly it may be that very cave in which he cut off Saul’s skirt, for David and his men might with great ease lie hid there and not be seen by him.”-Pococke’s Travels, vol. ii., part 1, p. 41.

Joseph Benson on 1 Samuel 24:3
Joseph Benson's Commentary · source PDF p. 267

Verse 3. Where was a cave — This cave being near the highway, and in the most frequented place of the wilderness, namely, near the sheep-cotes, to which the shepherds and herdsmen resorted to feed and milk their flocks, it is likely David made choice of it as being a place most unlikely to be suspected. Or, perhaps, he was pressed so near by Saul that he had no other way of escaping. That his distress and danger were very great, may be gathered from the 57th and 142d Psalms, which, it is supposed, he composed in commemoration of his deliverance. Saul went in to cover his feet — To take some rest in sleep. Being a military man, it is probable he used to sleep with his soldiers upon the ground. And it is not improbable that, being weary with his eager and almost incessant pursuit, first of David, then of the Philistines, and now of David again, he both needed and desired some sleep; God also disposing him thereto, that David might have this eminent occasion to demonstrate his integrity to Saul, and to all Israel. In the sides of the cave — For that there were vast caves in those parts is affirmed, not only by Josephus, but also by heathen authors; Strabo writes of one which could receive four thousand men.

Joseph Sutcliffe on 1 Samuel 24:3
Joseph Sutcliffe's Commentary · source PDF p. 752

Ver. 3. Saul went in to cover his feet; a modest phrase for easing nature; and laying aside his robe, David now approached and cut off a small part.

Daniel Whedon on 1 Samuel 24:3
Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testament · source PDF p. 560

3. The sheepcotes by the way — Not caves in the rocks, but enclosures built by the shepherds in the valley for the purpose of protecting their flocks. These sheep perhaps belonged to Nabal. Compare 1 Samuel 25:7. To cover his feet — Not to lie down for sleep, for that idea could have been expressed more simply, but a euphemism for performing the necessities of nature, which was done in a sitting posture, the person covering himself with the folds of his garment. Compare Judges 3:24. In the sides of the cave — The note on 1 Samuel 22:1, on the cave of Adullam, shows that these mountain caverns afforded sufficient room for all the facts here mentioned.

Cited across the library (3 references)
4

And the men of David said unto him, Behold the day of which the LORD said unto thee, Behold, I will deliver thine enemy into thine hand, that thou mayest do to him as it shall seem good unto thee. Then David arose, and cut off the skirt of Saul’s robe privily.

John Wesley on 1 Samuel 24:4
John Wesley's Explanatory Notes · source PDF p. 70

V. 4. Behold, &c.-Not that God had said these words, or made any such promise; but they put this construction upon those promises which God had made to him, of delivering him from all his enemies, and carrying him through all difficulties to the throne. This promise they conceived put him under an obligation of taking all opportunities which God put into his hand for their accomplishment.

Adam Clarke on 1 Samuel 24:4
Clarke's Commentary · source PDF p. 144

Verse 4. And the men of David said] We know not to what promise of God the men of David refer; they perhaps meant no more than to say, “Behold, the Lord hath delivered thine enemy into thy land, now do to him as he wishes to do to thee.”

Then David arose] Though I have a high opinion of the character of David, yet the circumstances of the case seem to indicate that he arose to take away the life of Saul, and that it was in reference to this that his heart smote him. It appears that he rose up immediately at the desire of his men to slay his inveterate enemy, and one whom he knew the Lord had rejected; but when about to do it he was prevented by the remonstrance of God in his conscience, and instead of cutting off his head, as he might have done, an act which the laws and usages of war would have justified, he contented himself with cutting off the skirt of his robe; and he did this only to show Saul how much he had been in his power.

Joseph Benson on 1 Samuel 24:4
Joseph Benson's Commentary · source PDF p. 267

Verse 4. The men of David said unto him, &c. — The cave being very large, and David and his men at the further end of it, they might see Saul by the light of the entrance, without his seeing them, and might whisper together what follows without being heard. The Lord said unto thee, Behold, I will deliver, &c. — We do not read anywhere that God said these very words, or made a promise to deliver Saul into David’s hands. But they put this construction on what Samuel had said about taking the kingdom from Saul and giving it to David, and on those promises which God had made to him of delivering him from all his enemies, and carrying him through all difficulties to the throne. These promises, they conceived, laid him under an obligation of taking all opportunities which God put into his hands for their accomplishment. Add to this, that, having a desire to return to their own habitations, and also to have preferment under David, they wished him to seize this occasion which now presented itself of destroying his enemy, and advancing himself. Then David arose and cut off the skirt of Saul’s robe privily — Which he might easily do, as he was asleep.

Joseph Sutcliffe on 1 Samuel 24:4
Joseph Sutcliffe's Commentary · source PDF p. 752

Ver. 4. I will deliver thine enemy into thy hand. Rabbi Lyranus says, that Samuel had told him this when his wife had aided his escape from the executioners sent by Saul.

Daniel Whedon on 1 Samuel 24:4
Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testament · source PDF p. 560

4. Behold the day of which the Lord said unto thee — We have no mention elsewhere of any such oracle as this, though David may have received it through Gad or Abiathar. But probably we should understand it as a free construction by David’s friends of all such prophecies and events as had designated this son of Jesse for the throne of Israel. 1 Samuel 15:28; 16:1, 12; 20:15; 23:17. The skirt of Saul’s robe — A corner or flap of his outer garment. This garment Saul had probably laid off when he entered the cave, and so David was able the more easily to cut a piece from it unobserved by the king.

5

And it came to pass afterward, that David’s heart smote him, because he had cut off Saul’s skirt.

Joseph Benson on 1 Samuel 24:5–6
Joseph Benson's Commentary · source PDF p. 268

Verses 5, 6. David’s heart smote him — His intention in cutting off Saul’s skirt was only to give certain proof that he did not seek his life, in that he had spared it when it was wholly in his power; yet no sooner had he done it, but the consideration how Saul might be affected by it, whether it might not enrage him the more, and how the action might be esteemed by others, troubled him greatly. And he said to his men — When he returned to them, and they again pressed him, as is probable, to kill Saul; The Lord forbid, &c. — He considers Saul now, not as his enemy, and the only person that stood in the way of his preferment, (for then he would have been induced to hearken to the temptation,) but as his master, to whom he was obliged to be faithful, and as the Lord’s anointed, whom God had appointed to reign as long as he lived, and who, as such, was under the particular protection of the divine law.

Daniel Whedon on 1 Samuel 24:5
Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testament · source PDF p. 561

5. David’s heart smote him — He felt that even the rending of Saul’s garment was going too far against the Lord’s anointed. Clarke supposes that David arose with the purpose of killing Saul, but was prevented by the remonstrance of God in his conscience; but we see no sufficient evidence of such purpose.

6

And he said unto his men, The LORD forbid that I should do this thing unto my master, the LORD’s anointed, to stretch forth mine hand against him, seeing he is the anointed of the LORD.

Adam Clarke on 1 Samuel 24:6
Clarke's Commentary · source PDF p. 145

Verse 6. The Lord’s anointed] However unworthily Saul was now acting, he had been appointed to his high office by God himself, and he could only be removed by the authority which placed him on the throne. Even David, who knew he was appointed to reign in his stead, and whose life Saul had often sought to destroy, did not conceive that he had any right to take away his life; and he grounds the reasons of his forbearance on this-He is my master, I am his subject. He is the Lord’s anointed, and therefore sacred as to his person in the Lord’s sight. It is an awful thing to kill a king, even the most untoward, when he has once been constitutionally appointed to the throne. No experiment of this kind has ever succeeded; the Lord abhors king killing. Had David taken away the life of Saul at this time, he would, in the sight of God, have been a murderer.

Cited across the library (1 reference)
7

So David stayed his servants with these words, and suffered them not to rise against Saul. But Saul rose up out of the cave, and went on his way.

Adam Clarke on 1 Samuel 24:7
Clarke's Commentary · source PDF p. 145

Verse 7. Suffered them not to rise against Saul.] As he could restrain them, it was his duty to do so; had he connived at their killing him, David would have been the murderer. In praying for the king we call God the only Ruler of princes, for this simple reason, that their authority is the highest among men, and next to that of God himself; hence he alone is above them. We find this sentiment well expressed by an elegant poet:— Regum timendorum in proprios greges,

Reges in ipsos imperium est Jovis.

HORACE, Odar. lib. iii., Od. i., ver. 5.

Kings are supreme over their own subjects;

Jove is supreme over kings themselves.

Joseph Benson on 1 Samuel 24:7–8
Joseph Benson's Commentary · source PDF p. 268

Verses 7, 8. And suffered them not to rise against Saul — He not only would not do this ill thing himself, but he would not suffer those about him to do it. Thus did he render good for evil to him, from whom he had received evil for good; and was herein both a type of Christ, who saved his persecutors, and an example to all Christians, not to be overcome of evil, but to overcome evil with good. David also went out of the cave, and cried after Saul — A bold attempt this, to adventure to come into the presence of such an enraged enemy. But his innocence, and confidence in God, imboldened him, especially having so strong an evidence to give of his integrity.

Daniel Whedon on 1 Samuel 24:7
Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testament · source PDF p. 561

7. David stayed his servants — Literally, He split them. Vulgate: confregit; he broke them to pieces. The idea is, that by his words he completely nonplussed them, so as to check their furious desire to make an end of Saul.

Cited across the library (3 references)
8

David also arose afterward, and went out of the cave, and cried after Saul, saying, My Lord the king. And when Saul looked behind him, David stooped with his face to the earth, and bowed himself.

9

And David said to Saul, Wherefore hearest thou men’s words, saying, Behold, David seeketh thy hurt?

10

Behold, this day thine eyes have seen how that the LORD had delivered thee to day into mine hand in the cave: and some bade me kill thee: but mine eye spared thee; and I said, I will not put forth mine hand against my Lord; for he is the LORD’s anointed.

John Wesley on 1 Samuel 24:10
John Wesley's Explanatory Notes · source PDF p. 70

V. 10. Mine eye-The eye is said to spare, because it affects the heart with pity, and moves a man to spare.

Joseph Benson on 1 Samuel 24:10–12
Joseph Benson's Commentary · source PDF p. 268

Verses 10-12. Mine eye spared thee — A phrase signifying the taking pity on those whom we have it in our power to hurt. The eye is said to spare, because it affects the heart, and induces a person to spare. Moreover, my father — Such he was through David’s marriage of his daughter. The Lord avenge me of thee — Rather, will avenge me; that is, vindicate and deliver me from thy violent and unjust persecution. For he does not, in these words, pray God to punish Saul for the injuries he had done him, but to justify, clear, and protect himself. But my hand shall not be upon thee — He was resolved not to return evil for evil, or to avenge himself, but to leave it to God to do him right.

11

Moreover, my father, see, yea, see the skirt of thy robe in my hand: for in that I cut off the skirt of thy robe, and killed thee not, know thou and see that there is neither evil nor transgression in mine hand, and I have not sinned against thee; yet thou huntest my soul to take it.

Daniel Whedon on 1 Samuel 24:11
Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testament · source PDF p. 561

11. My father, see — A reverential form of addressing an esteemed superior, (2 Kings 2:12; 5:13,) but in this place it may mean more. Saul was David’s father in law, and by this address the son of Jesse shows the king a childlike respect and reverence. It was a word of love that touched the heart of Saul, and brought the response My son. Verse 16.

12

The LORD judge between me and thee, and the LORD avenge me of thee: but mine hand shall not be upon thee.

John Wesley on 1 Samuel 24:12
John Wesley's Explanatory Notes · source PDF p. 70

V. 12. Will avenge-If thou persistest in thy injuries and cruel designs against me.

Adam Clarke on 1 Samuel 24:12
Clarke's Commentary · source PDF p. 145

Verse 12. The Lord judge between me and thee] Appeals of this kind to God are the common refuge of the poor and oppressed people. So also among the Hindoos: God will judge between us. Mother Kalee will judge. Sometimes this springs from a consciousness of innocence, and sometimes from a desire of revenge.

13

As saith the proverb of the ancients, Wickedness proceedeth from the wicked: but mine hand shall not be upon thee.

John Wesley on 1 Samuel 24:13
John Wesley's Explanatory Notes · source PDF p. 70

V. 13. Wickedness, &c.-That is, wicked men will do wicked actions, among which this is one, to kill their sovereign lord and king; and therefore if I were so wicked a person as thy courtiers represent me, I should make no conscience of laying violent hands upon thee.

Adam Clarke on 1 Samuel 24:13
Clarke's Commentary · source PDF p. 145

Verse 13. Wickedness proceeded from the wicked] This proverb may be thus understood: He that does a wicked act, gives proof thereby that he is a wicked man. From him who is wicked, wickedness will proceed; he who is wicked will add one iniquity to another. Had I conspired to dethrone thee, I should have taken thy life when it was in my power, and thus added wickedness to wickedness.

Joseph Benson on 1 Samuel 24:13
Joseph Benson's Commentary · source PDF p. 269

Verse 13. Wickedness proceedeth from the wicked — That is, men may be known by their actions; wicked men will do wicked actions; among which, this is one, to kill their sovereign lord and king; and, therefore, if I were so wicked a person as I am represented by thy courtiers to be, I should now have shown it, I should have made no conscience of laying violent hands upon thee.

Daniel Whedon on 1 Samuel 24:13
Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testament · source PDF p. 561

13. Wickedness proceedeth from the wicked — And therefore were I the wicked man that some represent me, (verse 9,) I would have wrought wickedness against the king when it lay in my power. But the fact that I leave Jehovah to avenge me, and refuse to lift my hand against the king, shows that wickedness proceedeth not from me. These words of David also contain a tacit implication that wickedness was proceeding from Saul.

14

After whom is the king of Israel come out? after whom dost thou pursue? after a dead dog, after a flea.

Adam Clarke on 1 Samuel 24:14
Clarke's Commentary · source PDF p. 146

Verse 14. After a dead dog] A term used among the Hebrews to signify the most sovereign contempt; see 2 Samuel 16:9. One utterly incapable of making the least resistance against Saul, and the troops of Israel. The same idea is expressed in the term flea. The Targum properly expresses both thus: one who is weak, one who is contemptible.

Joseph Benson on 1 Samuel 24:14–15
Joseph Benson's Commentary · source PDF p. 269

Verses 14, 15. After whom is the king of Israel come out? — David here employs every persuasive art to move Saul. He represents himself in as contemptible a light as possible; that he might convince Saul it was not for his honour to take so much pains to kill him, if he could do it. The Lord, therefore, be judge — He thought he could not repeat this too often, that as he had done hitherto, so he still resolved hereafter, to leave it to God to judge which of them was in the right, and not to avenge himself.

Daniel Whedon on 1 Samuel 24:14
Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testament · source PDF p. 561

14. After a dead dog, after a flea — A term of contempt and a term of insignificance. By these terms David represents himself as one so contemptible and insignificant that it was beneath the dignity of Israel’s royal monarch to pursue him.

Cited across the library (1 reference)
15

The LORD therefore be judge, and judge between me and thee, and see, and plead my cause, and deliver me out of thine hand.

Adam Clarke on 1 Samuel 24:15
Clarke's Commentary · source PDF p. 146

Verse 15. The Lord therefore be judge] Let God determine who is guilty.

16

And it came to pass, when David had made an end of speaking these words unto Saul, that Saul said, Is this thy voice, my son David? And Saul lifted up his voice, and wept.

John Wesley on 1 Samuel 24:16
John Wesley's Explanatory Notes · source PDF p. 71

V. 16. Thy voice-He knew his voice, though being at a great distance from him, he could not discern his face. Wept-From the sense of his sin against God, and his base carriage to David. He speaks as one quite overcome with David’s kindness, and as one that relents at the sight of his own folly and ingratitude.

Adam Clarke on 1 Samuel 24:16
Clarke's Commentary · source PDF p. 146

Verse 16. My son David?] David had called Saul his master, lord, and king. Saul accosts him here as his son, to show that he felt perfectly reconciled to him, and wished to receive him as formerly into his family.

Joseph Benson on 1 Samuel 24:16
Joseph Benson's Commentary · source PDF p. 269

Verse 16. Is this thy voice, my son David? — He knew his voice, though, being at a great distance from him, he could not discern his face. Saul lifted up his voice and wept — Being overcome with David’s kindness, in sparing his life when he could have taken it away, and conscious of his base carriage toward him. He speaks as one that relented at the sight of his own folly and ingratitude. “David’s kindness,” says Samuel Clark, “drew tears from hard-hearted Saul, as Moses fetched water out of the flinty rock,” Deuteronomy 8:15. Perhaps, however, he was also affected with a sense of his sins against God. But it does not appear from his future conduct that he was a true penitent, for he did not bring forth fruits meet for repentance.

Daniel Whedon on 1 Samuel 24:16
Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testament · source PDF p. 561

16. Saul lifted up his voice, and wept — “Behold,” says Kitto, “how that stern heart is melted! The hard wintry frosts thaw fast before the kindly warmth of David’s generous nature.”

17

And he said to David, Thou art more righteous than I: for thou hast rewarded me good, whereas I have rewarded thee evil.

John Wesley on 1 Samuel 24:17
John Wesley's Explanatory Notes · source PDF p. 71

V. 17. More righteous than I-He ingenuously acknowledges David’s integrity, and his own iniquity.

Joseph Benson on 1 Samuel 24:17–19
Joseph Benson's Commentary · source PDF p. 269

Verses 17-19. Thou art more righteous than I — He ingenuously acknowledges David’s integrity and his own iniquity. If a man find his enemy, will he let him go? — That is, he will certainly destroy him to save himself. Thy behaviour, therefore, shows that thou hast no enmity to me. Wherefore the Lord reward thee good — Because he thought himself not able to recompense so great a favour, he prays God to recompense it.

Cited across the library (1 reference)
18

And thou hast shewed this day how that thou hast dealt well with me: forasmuch as when the LORD had delivered me into thine hand, thou killedst me not.

19

For if a man find his enemy, will he let him go well away? wherefore the LORD reward thee good for that thou hast done unto me this day.

John Wesley on 1 Samuel 24:19
John Wesley's Explanatory Notes · source PDF p. 71

V. 19. The Lord reward thee-Because he thought himself not able to recompense so great a favour, he prays God to recompense it.

Adam Clarke on 1 Samuel 24:19
Clarke's Commentary · source PDF p. 146

Verse 19. If a man find his enemy, will he let him go well away?] Or rather, Will he send him in a good way? But Houbigant translates the whole clause thus: Si quis, inimicum suum reperiens, dimittit eum in viam bonam, redditur ei adomino sua merces; “If a man, finding his enemy, send him by a good way, the Lord will give him his reward.” The words which are here put in italic, are not in the Hebrew text, but they are found, at least in the sense, in the Septuagint, Syriac, and Arabic, and seem necessary to complete the sense; therefore, adds Saul, the Lord will reward thee good for what thou hast done unto me.

20

And now, behold, I know well that thou shalt surely be king, and that the kingdom of Israel shall be established in thine hand.

Adam Clarke on 1 Samuel 24:20
Clarke's Commentary · source PDF p. 146

Verse 20. I know well that thou shalt surely be king] Hebrew, Reigning, thou shalt reign. He knew this before; and yet he continued to pursue him with the most deadly hatred.

Joseph Benson on 1 Samuel 24:20–21
Joseph Benson's Commentary · source PDF p. 270

Verses 20, 21. And now I know well that thou shalt surely be king — These wonderful dispensations of Divine Providence over David, and David’s no less wonderful virtue, at last convinced Saul that God designed him to be the king of his people, and that none could hinder his establishment. That thou wilt not destroy my name, &c. — As it was usual for kings to do in those days, generally destroying the families of those to whose thrones they were advanced.

Joseph Sutcliffe on 1 Samuel 24:20
Joseph Sutcliffe's Commentary · source PDF p. 752

Ver. 20. Thou shalt surely be king. It was the general opinion in the army and nation, that David should succeed to the throne.

Daniel Whedon on 1 Samuel 24:20
Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testament · source PDF p. 561

20. I know well that thou shalt surely be king — The anointing by Samuel, the triumph over Goliath, the homage paid him by the enthusiastic people, and all the providential deliverances from the deadly pursuits of Saul, together with this last affair in the cave, thoroughly convinced the king that David was that neighbour who, according to Samuel’s prophecy, (1 Samuel 15:28,) was destined to succeed him on the throne. Here again, in fact, Saul is among the prophets, and thus confirms by his own words the predictions of Samuel.

21

Swear now therefore unto me by the LORD, that thou wilt not cut off my seed after me, and that thou wilt not destroy my name out of my father’s house.

Adam Clarke on 1 Samuel 24:21
Clarke's Commentary · source PDF p. 146

Verse 21. Swear now] Saul knew that an oath would bind David, though it was insufficient to bind himself; see 1 Samuel 19:6. He had sworn to his son Jonathan that David should not be slain; and yet sought by all means in his power to destroy him!

22

And David sware unto Saul. And Saul went home; but David and his men gat them up unto the hold.

Editorial note: Editorial correction at 1 Samuel 24:22: this text restores “sware” in place of “swear” in the past-tense clause. The original plain / numbered-edition difference was “swear” / “sware” (KJV_OT.PDF, PDF p. 676; STR_KJVO.PDF, PDF p. 813). The supplied numbered edition and the 1873 Cambridge Paragraph Bible, PDF p. 390, support the correction. The separately obtained Gutenberg KJV also supports this exact correction. Restore the attested KJV past-tense form sware/swarest in the exact clause. The supplied reading is preserved in this note. Project Gutenberg, KJV, eBook 10; Scrivener, Cambridge Paragraph Bible (1873), PDF p. 390.

John Wesley on 1 Samuel 24:22
John Wesley's Explanatory Notes · source PDF p. 71

V. 22. Unto the hold-Of En-gedi, ver. 1, for having had by frequent experience of Saul’s inconstancy, he would trust him no more.

Adam Clarke on 1 Samuel 24:22
Clarke's Commentary · source PDF p. 146

Verse 22. Saul went home] Confounded at a sense of his own baseness, and overwhelmed with a sense of David’s generosity.

David and his men gat them up unto the hold.] Went up to Mizpeh, according to the Syriac and Arabic. David could not trust Saul with his life; the utmost he could expect from him was that he should cease from persecuting him; but even this was too much to expect from a man of such a character as Saul. He was no longer under the Divine guidance; an evil spirit had full dominion over his soul. What God fills not, the devil will occupy.

Joseph Benson on 1 Samuel 24:22
Joseph Benson's Commentary · source PDF p. 270

Verse 22. David and his men get them up unto the hold — Of Engedi, verse 1. For having had so frequent experience of Saul’s inconstancy, he would trust him no more. It is indeed dangerous to trust a reconciled enemy; and the son of Sirach advises, “Never trust thine enemy; though he humble himself, yet take good heed and beware of him.” Before we close our notes on this chapter, we beg leave to add one general remark; which is, that there is something so noble and generous in David’s whole behaviour, as related in it, that it is above all encomiums. We cannot say any thing in commendation of it, but what the relation itself far exceeds.

Daniel Whedon on 1 Samuel 24:22
Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testament · source PDF p. 562

22. The hold — The particular stronghold in this wilderness (chap. xxiii, 29) in which at the time David and his men had their headquarters. Yielding himself now to holy meditation and song, he commemorates his deliverance by the composition of Psalm 142.

Closing reflections and analysis

Joseph Sutcliffe

REFLECTIONS.

The destruction of David being the leading passion of Saul, he scarcely allowed himself time to check the Philistines, before he returned to the most dishonourable pursuit of the best of men. Malice, when rooted in the heart, is the most awful of human passions.

Saul was subtle as well as malicious; and so much so, that the vigilant David was in a manner surprised a second time. But behold him, who laid a snare for another, fall into a mortifying snare which no man had laid for his feet. While the army marched on, Saul alone approached the cave, being watched by David and his friends. The king, not suspecting the presence of an enemy, ventured to enter and enjoy the shade. And David’s friends, on Saul’s approach, had not been wanting to remind him that the promise by Samuel or Gad, was now accomplished, that God would deliver his enemy into his hand. Yea, David himself could not forget the spear twice thrown to pierce him; nor would Abiathar be wanting to plead for the just vengeance of his father’s blood, and the blood of all his brethren. But a servant of God must never do an action unworthy of his holy name. A son must never conspire against a father. No crown becomes a virtuous prince but a crown of righteousness.

Saul, unconscious Saul, had scarcely retired from the cave, before a voice cried after him, My lord—my father! He turned and saw David, sometimes bowing to the earth, and sometimes holding up the shred of his robe. He wondered and listened to the defence of his son. Struck for the moment with the risk he had run, and amazed to find in David a protector, his soul softened; the tears flowed, and truth raised her voice above prejudice and passion. He acknowledged his errors, and the superior rectitude of his son. Now the friends of Saul and of David gather round to hear the extraordinary conversation; now the two armies approach, but not to fight. It is not to destroy David, but to contract a covenant with him, and to do him homage as the king of Israel.

But how shall Doeg show his face at this interview? How shall he meet the eyes of David, and of Abiathar? How shall all the liars, and all the flatterers of Saul, who had whispered in the royal ear a thousand treasons against David, lift up their head? The shred of the robe makes them all afraid: and the eyes of one innocent man covers the countenance of a thousand culprits with confusion. And how, we may farther ask, will this guilty world, who have made light of Christ and his gospel, and who have offered ten thousand indignities to his name and to his church, dare to see him on his throne? By and by their feet will fall into the cave; and happy if they may find a David to let his enemies go. Let the christian be instructed by this interview concerning the weapons of his warfare; they are not carnal, but mighty through grace. Yesterday it was rebel David, traitor David, and a price was set on his head. To-day, it is “my son David.” The live coal had thawed the heart of Saul.

Saul, defective in virtue and often imprudent, was not defective in common sense. He acknowledged David as the successor to the crown; and wisely stipulated for the protection of his house. This was a measure of consummate policy, and happy in its effects. So he parted from David grateful that he had shed tears, not blood. He returned humbled indeed, and branded in his robe, but that was far better than to have it stained with innocent blood.

If Saul was prudent, David was still more so. He still preferred his hold, which secured a partial safety, and a retreat at pleasure to the desert, to a mansion in the court. He preferred the goats and sheep for neighbours rather than Saul’s courtiers; he was but too well acquainted with the variable temper of the king. He wisely feared that the tears of Saul were only as the giving of a frosty day, when acted upon by the warmth of noon; in the evening the cold prevails with a greater power than before. Hence we should endeavour to live peaceably if possible with wicked men, but not to put ourselves in their power. We should also learn, that transient tears for past faults are no marks of genuine repentance, unless they are followed by the correspondent fruits of faith, obedience and love.