WesleyanHeritage Library Search
Menu
Deuteronomy · 20 verses

Deuteronomy 20

Read slowly. Let the words lead you to Christ.

Chapter introductions

John Wesley

CHAPTER 20.

The exhortation of the priest to them who were going to battle, ver. 1-4. The dismission of them who were engaged in business, or faint-hearted, ver. 5-9. How they were to treat distant cities, ver. 10-15. The cities of the Canaanites, ver. 16-18. Fruit-trees not to be destroyed, ver. 19, 20.

Adam Clarke

CHAPTER 20

Directions concerning campaigns, 1. The priest shall encourage the people with the assurance that God will accompany and fight for them, 2-4. The officers shalt dismiss from the army all who had just built a new house, but had not dedicated it, 5. All who had planted a vineyard, but had not yet eaten of its fruits, 6. All who had betrothed a wife, but had not brought her home, 7. And all who were timid and faint-hearted, 8. The commanders to be chosen after the timid, &c., had retired, 9. No city to be attacked till they had proclaimed conditions of peace to it, provided it be a city beyond the bounds of the seven Canaanitish nations; if it submitted, it was to become tributary; if not, it was to be besieged, sacked, and all the males put to the sword; the women, children, and cattle to be taken as booty, 19-15. No such offers to be made to the cities of the Canaanites; of them nothing shall be preserved, and the reason, 16-18. In besieging a city no trees to be cut down but those which do not bear fruit, 19, 20.

NOTES ON CHAP. 20

Joseph Benson

CHAPTER 20.

A.M. 2553. — B.C. 1451.

The exhortation of the priest to them who were going to battle, 1-4. The dismission of them who were engaged in business, or faint-hearted, 5-9. How they were to treat distant cities, 10-15. The cities of the Canaanites, 16-18. Fruit-trees not to be destroyed, 19, 20.

NOTES ON CHAPTER 20.

Joseph Sutcliffe

CHAPTER 20.

Daniel Whedon

CHAPTER 20.

DIRECTIONS IN REFERENCE TO FUTURE WARS.

These rules of war have their application to nations other than the Canaanitish.

1

When thou goest out to battle against thine enemies, and seest horses, and chariots, and a people more than thou, be not afraid of them: for the LORD thy God is with thee, which brought thee up out of the land of Egypt.

Adam Clarke on Deuteronomy 20:1
Clarke's Commentary · source PDF p. 85

Verse 1. When thou goest out to battle] This refers chiefly to the battles they were to have with the Canaanites, in order to get possession of the promised land; for it cannot be considered to apply to any wars which they might have with the surrounding nations for political reasons, as the Divine assistance could not be expected in wars which were not undertaken by the Divine command.

Joseph Benson on Deuteronomy 20:1
Joseph Benson's Commentary · source PDF p. 781

Verse 1. When thou goest out to battle against thine enemies — The land of Canaan being to be gained by conquest, in a war of God’s special appointment; and the Israelites, after their settlement in it, being likely to be exposed to invasions from, or quarrels with the neighbouring nations, Moses judged it necessary to leave them some standing rules for their conduct in both these kinds of war. The first and great rule was, to commit their cause to God, depending with entire confidence upon that divine power which had so often and so wonderfully delivered them, without the least fear or discouragement at the superior force or terrible appearance of their enemies. And seest horses and chariots — The armies of the Israelites consisted wholly of foot, and their law seems to have obliged them to continue so, in order that their reliance might be entirely on God, Deuteronomy 17:16. But the Egyptians, Canaanites, and other nations, had the advantage of horses and chariots, in which they placed their confidence. Thus the psalmist: “Some trust in chariots and some in horses, but we will remember the name of the Lord our God.” These chariots were sometimes armed with scythes, to rush in among the foot, and cut them down like grass, which made them very formidable. These are the chariots of iron, mentioned Judges 4:3.

Daniel Whedon on Deuteronomy 20:1
Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testament · source PDF p. 637

1. Seest horses, and chariots — Of the military resources of the Oriental nations, with whom the Israelites would be likely to be brought in hostile contact, cavalry constituted an important part. The Egyptians and the Syrians are especially mentioned for the abundance of their cavalry. Be not afraid — The Israelites are to call to mind their past history, when Jehovah overthrew the horse and the rider when he so triumphantly brought up his people out of Egypt.

2

And it shall be, when ye are come nigh unto the battle, that the priest shall approach and speak unto the people,

John Wesley on Deuteronomy 20:2
John Wesley's Explanatory Notes · source PDF p. 577

V. 2. Speak unto the people-Probably to one regiment of the army after another.

Adam Clarke on Deuteronomy 20:2
Clarke's Commentary · source PDF p. 85

Verse 2. The priest shall approach, and speak unto the people] The priest on these occasions was the representative of that God whose servant he was, and whose worship he conducted. It is remarkable that almost all ancient nations took their priests with them to battle, as they did not expect success without having the object of their adoration with them, and they supposed they secured his presence by having that of his representative.

Joseph Benson on Deuteronomy 20:2
Joseph Benson's Commentary · source PDF p. 781

Verse 2. The priest shall approach — The Jews say there was a priest anointed for the purpose, whose office, as we may gather from Numbers 31:6, was to blow with the trumpet when they were preparing for battle. And shall speak to the people — Probably exhorting them, in the most persuasive manner, to a courageous and undaunted performance of their duty, considering their cause as God’s, and relying on his protection and aid.

Daniel Whedon on Deuteronomy 20:2
Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testament · source PDF p. 637

2. The priest shall approach and speak unto the people — According to the rabbins, the priest who thus accompanied the army was called the “Anointed for the war.” He held a high rank. See Numbers 31:6.

Cited across the library (1 reference)
3

And shall say unto them, Hear, O Israel, ye approach this day unto battle against your enemies: let not your hearts faint, fear not, and do not tremble, neither be ye terrified because of them;

4

For the LORD your God is he that goeth with you, to fight for you against your enemies, to save you.

5

And the officers shall speak unto the people, saying, What man is there that hath built a new house, and hath not dedicated it? let him go and return to his house, lest he die in the battle, and another man dedicate it.

John Wesley on Deuteronomy 20:5
John Wesley's Explanatory Notes · source PDF p. 577

V. 5. What man-This and the following exceptions are to be understood only of a war allowed by God, not in a war commanded by God, not in the approaching war with the Canaanites, from which even the bridegroom was not exempted, as the Jewish writers note.

Adam Clarke on Deuteronomy 20:5
Clarke's Commentary · source PDF p. 85

Verse 5. That hath built a new house, and hath not dedicated it?] From the title of Psalm 30:1,-A Psalm or Song at the Dedication of the House of David-it is evident that it was a custom in Israel to dedicate a new house to God with prayer, praise, and thanksgiving; and this was done in order to secure the Divine presence and blessing, for no pious or sensible man could imagine he could dwell safely in a house that was not under the immediate protection of God. Hence it has been a custom in the most barbarous nations to consecrate a part of a new house to the deity they worshipped. The houses of the inhabitants of Bonny, in Africa, are generally divided into three apartments: one is a kind of state room or parlour; another serves for a common room, or kitchen; and the third is dedicated to the Juju, the serpent god, which they worship; for even those savages believe that in every house their god should have his temple! At the times of dedication among the Jews, besides prayer and praise, a feast was made, to which the relatives and neighbours were invited. Something of this custom is observed in some parts of our own country in what is called warming the house; but in these cases the feasting only is kept up-the prayer and praise forgotten! so that the dedication appears to be rather more to Bacchus than to Jehovah, the author of every good and perfect gift.

Joseph Benson on Deuteronomy 20:5–6
Joseph Benson's Commentary · source PDF p. 782

Verses 5, 6. What man is there — This and the following exceptions are to be understood only of a war allowed by God, not in a war commanded by God, not in the approaching war with the Canaanites, from which even the bridegroom was not exempt, as the Jewish writers note. Hath planted a vineyard — This and the former dispensation were generally convenient, but more necessary in the beginning of their settlement in Canaan, for the encouragement of those who should build houses or plant vineyards, which were chargeable to them, and beneficial to the commonwealth. Eaten of it — Hebrew, made it common; namely, for the use of himself, and family, and friends, which it was not till the fifth year.

Joseph Sutcliffe on Deuteronomy 20:5
Joseph Sutcliffe's Commentary · source PDF p. 503

Verse 5. Hath not dedicated it. David composed the xxxth Psalm for the dedication of his new palace. Good men warmed a new house by devotion.

Daniel Whedon on Deuteronomy 20:5
Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testament · source PDF p. 637

5. The officers — The shoterim, for that is the Hebrew term, were to be the keepers of the genealogical tables, and in that capacity would know who were the men bound to render military service.

Cited across the library (5 references)
6

And what man is he that hath planted a vineyard, and hath not yet eaten of it? let him also go and return unto his house, lest he die in the battle, and another man eat of it.

John Wesley on Deuteronomy 20:6
John Wesley's Explanatory Notes · source PDF p. 577

V. 6. A vineyard-This and the former dispensation were generally convenient, but more necessary in the beginning of their settlement in Canaan, for the encouragement of those who should build houses or plant vineyards, which was chargeable to them, and beneficial to the common-wealth. Eaten of it-Heb. made it common, namely, for the use of himself and family and friends, which it was not, ‘till the fifth year.

Daniel Whedon on Deuteronomy 20:6
Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testament · source PDF p. 637

6. Planted a vineyard — The word כרם is not to be restricted to vineyards. The same term is applied to olive groves. Hath not yet eaten of it — The Hebrew term חלל, to make common, is here used in the sense of to apply to common use. The fruit of the vine, or of fruit trees in general, was not to be gathered for use for the first three years. In the fourth year the fruit was to be consecrated to Jehovah. It was not till the fifth year that the fruit could be gathered for common use.

7

And what man is there that hath betrothed a wife, and hath not taken her? let him go and return unto his house, lest he die in the battle, and another man take her.

Adam Clarke on Deuteronomy 20:7
Clarke's Commentary · source PDF p. 86

Editorial note: Source collation note — source PDF page 86: “and his house unfinished. Του δε και αμφιδρυφης αλοχος φυλακη ελελειπρο, Και δομος ημιτελης\ τον δ᾽ εκτανε δαρδανος ανηρ, Νηος αποθρωσκοντα πολυ …”. Compared with CLA_DEU.PDF PDF p. 86. The source-font or layout comparison does not securely establish every letter, mark or local sequence in these passages. The flagged language readings or layout are retained; the original source pages should be consulted for these specific readings. Additional-source investigation: the available separately digitized printed volumes were searched, but the corresponding passage was not securely located. The flagged readings or layout remain uncertain; this search provides no basis for reconstructing or silently normalizing them. CLA_DEU.PDF, PDF page 86.

Verse 7. Betrothed a wife, and hath not taken her?] It was customary among the Jews to contract matrimony, espouse or betroth, and for some considerable time to leave the parties in the houses of their respective parents: when the bridegroom had made proper preparations, then the bride was brought home to his house, and thus the marriage was consummated. The provisions in this verse refer to a case of this kind; for it was deemed an excessive hardship for a person to be obliged to go to battle, where there was a probability of his being slain, who had left a new house unfinished; a newly purchased heritage half tilled; or a wife with whom he had just contracted marriage. Homer represents the case of Protesilaus as very afflicting, who was obliged to go to the Trojan war, leaving his wife in the deepest distress, and his house unfinished. Του δε και αμφιδρυφης αλοχος φυλακη ελελειπρο,

Και δομος ημιτελης\ τον δ᾽ εκτανε δαρδανος ανηρ,

Νηος αποθρωσκοντα πολυ πρωτιστον αχαιων.

ILIAD, 1. ii., ver. 100.

“A wife he left,

To rend in Phylace her bleeding cheeks,

And an unfinish’d mansion: first he died

Of all the Greeks; for as he leap’d to land,

Long ere the rest, a Dardan struck him dead.”

COWPER.

Joseph Benson on Deuteronomy 20:7–8
Joseph Benson's Commentary · source PDF p. 782

Verses 7, 8. Hath betrothed a wife — The time allowed in this case was a year, Deuteronomy 24:5. This was a law of great humanity, that conjugal love might not be disturbed, but have time to knit into a firm and lasting affection. What man is fearful and faint-hearted — This fearfulness is to be understood, say the Jews, not only of a natural timorousness, which is incident to some constitutions, and makes a man tremble at every danger, but of the adventitious terrors of a guilty conscience. For they did not, as in the modern fashion, send the wickedest and most worthless into the wars; but if they knew any man to be a notorious villain, they thrust him out of the army, lest his example should corrupt and discourage the rest of the soldiery.

Daniel Whedon on Deuteronomy 20:7
Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testament · source PDF p. 637

7. What man… hath betrothed a wife — The exemption from military service to the betrothed is, in 24:5, also applied to the newly married man, who was free from obligation to serve in the army for a year.

8

And the officers shall speak further unto the people, and they shall say, What man is there that is fearful and fainthearted? let him go and return unto his house, lest his brethren’s heart faint as well as his heart.

Adam Clarke on Deuteronomy 20:8
Clarke's Commentary · source PDF p. 87

Editorial note: Source collation note — paragraph 1: “and fainthearted?] the original רך rach, signifies tender or”. source PDF page 87: “and faint-hearted? The original רכ rach signifies tender or”. Compared with CLA_DEU.PDF PDF p. 87. The source-font or layout comparison does not securely establish every letter, mark or local sequence in these passages. The flagged language readings or layout are retained; the original source pages should be consulted for these specific readings. Additional-source investigation: an automated comparison of surrounding English text located possible corresponding passages in OCR from separately digitized printed volumes. The linked scan pages are research locators; their images have not been collated for this note's flagged readings. OCR agreement does not verify Greek or Hebrew letters, diacritics, word order, or table layout. The flagged readings or layout remain uncertain. CLA_DEU.PDF, PDF page 87; Additional printed-scan page locator (OCR context only; flagged reading unverified).

Verse 8. What man is there that is fearful and faint-hearted?] The original רך rach, signifies tender or soft-hearted. And a soft heart the man must have who, in such a contest, after such a permission, could turn his back upon his enemies and his brethren. However, such were the troops commanded by Gideon in his war against the Midianites; for after he gave this permission, out of 32,000 men only 10,000 remained to fight! Judges 7:3. There could be no deception in a business of this kind; for the departure of the 22,000 was the fullest proof of their dastardliness which they could possibly give.

Daniel Whedon on Deuteronomy 20:8
Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testament · source PDF p. 637

8. Fearful and fainthearted — These were to leave the army. Only the valorous were to constitute the force that was to go forth to battle.

9

And it shall be, when the officers have made an end of speaking unto the people that they shall make captains of the armies to lead the people.

John Wesley on Deuteronomy 20:9
John Wesley's Explanatory Notes · source PDF p. 577

V. 9. Make captains-Or rather, as the Hebrew hath it, they shall set or place the captains of the armies in the head or front of the people under their charge, that they may conduct them, and by their example encourage their soldiers. It is not likely they had their captains to make when they were just going to battle.

Joseph Benson on Deuteronomy 20:9
Joseph Benson's Commentary · source PDF p. 782

Verse 9. They shall make captains — Or rather, as the Hebrew is, they shall set or place the captains of the armies in the head or front of the people under their charge, that they may conduct them, and, by their example, encourage their soldiers. It is not likely they had their captain to make when they were just going to battle.

Joseph Sutcliffe on Deuteronomy 20:9
Joseph Sutcliffe's Commentary · source PDF p. 503

Ver. 9. The officers—shall make captains. The sense of this verse is difficult to gather. The readings vary; but Le Clerc’s translation is to be preferred. “When the heralds have made an end of speaking, the officers in front of the army shall number the troops.” The original word is rendered number in 1 Samuel 13:15; and muster in Isaiah 13:4.

Daniel Whedon on Deuteronomy 20:9
Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testament · source PDF p. 638

9. Captains of the armies to lead the people — The shoterim, or officers, after the elimination of the above-ordered army, are to appoint captains to lead the force that is now ready for the contest.

Cited across the library (1 reference)
10

When thou comest nigh unto a city to fight against it, then proclaim peace unto it.

Adam Clarke on Deuteronomy 20:10
Clarke's Commentary · source PDF p. 87

Verse 10. Proclaim peace unto it.] Interpreters are greatly divided concerning the objects of this law. The text, taken in connection with the context, (see Deuteronomy 20:15-18,) appears to state that this proclamation or offer of peace to a city is only to be understood of those cities which were situated beyond the limits of the seven anathematized nations, because these latter are commanded to be totally destroyed. Nothing can be clearer than this from the bare letter of the text, unless some of the words, taken separately, can be shown to have a different meaning. For the common interpretation, the following reasons are given. God, who knows all things, saw that they were incurable in their idolatry; that the cup of their iniquity was full; and as their Creator, Sovereign, and Judge, he determined to destroy them from off the face of the earth, “lest they should teach the Israelites to do after all their abominations,” Deuteronomy 20:18. After all, many plausible arguments have been brought to prove that even these seven Canaanitish nations might be received into mercy, provided they, 1. Renounced their idolatry; 2. Became subject to the Jews; and, 3. Paid annual tribute: and that it was only in case these terms were rejected, that they were not to leave alive in such a city any thing that breathed, Deuteronomy 20:16.

Joseph Sutcliffe on Deuteronomy 20:10
Joseph Sutcliffe's Commentary · source PDF p. 503

Ver. 10. Proclaim peace to it. In the Jugurthine war, Sallust names a city of Africa that had but two hours’ notice of the approach of the Roman armies, and they put every soul to the sword. While Sallust blushes to relate this, he palliates the carnage by saying, it was for the good of the Roman people! This cruelty is common enough in many wars; but the Hebrew lawgiver could not endure it. If the city refused the terms, then the war was placed on equal ground. Yet the spirit of the Messiah’s kingdom is evidently, according to all the prophets, a spirit of concord and peace. Isaiah 9. Mic. 4. Zechariah 9. Its aim is to make the earth one family, and Messiah the universal king.

Daniel Whedon on Deuteronomy 20:10–20
Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testament · source PDF p. 638

10-20. In these verses are given directions designed to prevent unnecessary destruction of life and property.

Daniel Whedon on Deuteronomy 20:10
Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testament · source PDF p. 638

10. Proclaim peace unto it — The meaning of the passage seems to be, summon it to surrender without contest.

11

And it shall be, if it make thee answer of peace, and open unto thee, then it shall be, that all the people that is found therein shall be tributaries unto thee, and they shall serve thee.

Daniel Whedon on Deuteronomy 20:11
Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testament · source PDF p. 638

11. If… answer of peace,… tributaries — If the city opened its gates and peacefully surrendered, all the inhabitants were to be spared, but they were to be tributaries of the Israelites.

12

And if it will make no peace with thee, but will make war against thee, then thou shalt besiege it:

Daniel Whedon on Deuteronomy 20:12
Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testament · source PDF p. 638

12. If it will make no peace — If the city does not submit without fighting, then it is to be besieged, and, when taken by storm, the armed men are to be put to death, the women and children spared.

13

And when the LORD thy God hath delivered it into thine hands, thou shalt smite every male thereof with the edge of the sword:

14

But the women, and the little ones, and the cattle, and all that is in the city, even all the spoil thereof, shalt thou take unto thyself; and thou shalt eat the spoil of thine enemies, which the LORD thy God hath given thee.

15

Thus shalt thou do unto all the cities which are very far off from thee, which are not of the cities of these nations.

Daniel Whedon on Deuteronomy 20:15
Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testament · source PDF p. 638

15. Cities… not of… these nations — The directions from verses 10-15 are designed to apply to the nations with whom in the future wars may be waged. The nations of Canaan were to be utterly destroyed.

16

But of the cities of these people, which the LORD thy God doth give thee for an inheritance, thou shalt save alive nothing that breatheth:

John Wesley on Deuteronomy 20:16
John Wesley's Explanatory Notes · source PDF p. 577

V. 16. Nothing-No man. For the beasts, some few excepted, were given them for a prey.

Joseph Benson on Deuteronomy 20:16
Joseph Benson's Commentary · source PDF p. 782

Verse 16. Thou shalt save alive nothing — No human creature; for the beasts, some few excepted, were given for a prey. This slaughter of all the people is to be understood only in case they did not surrender when summoned, but rejected the conditions of peace when offered them. In which case their condition was worse than that of any other people, whose males only were to be slain, verse 14.

Daniel Whedon on Deuteronomy 20:16
Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testament · source PDF p. 638

16. Of these people — The Canaanites and kindred nations. Thou shalt save alive nothing — Not a human being was to be left alive. The abominations of these idolatrous nations were such that only by obliterating them wholly could the Israelites be exempt from their corruptions. The punishment of the Canaanites seems severe, but shall not the Judge of all the earth do right?

17

But thou shalt utterly destroy them; namely, the Hittites, and the Amorites, the Canaanites, and the Perizzites, the Hivites, and the Jebusites; as the LORD thy God hath commanded thee:

Adam Clarke on Deuteronomy 20:17
Clarke's Commentary · source PDF p. 87

Editorial note: Source collation note — paragraph 1: “provided we could translate כי החרם תחרימם hi hacharem tacharimem, thou”. source PDF page 87: “provided we could translate תחרימם החרם כי hi hacharem tacharimem, thou”. Compared with CLA_DEU.PDF PDF p. 87. The source-font or layout comparison does not securely establish every letter, mark or local sequence in these passages. The flagged language readings or layout are retained; the original source pages should be consulted for these specific readings. Additional-source investigation: an automated comparison of surrounding English text located possible corresponding passages in OCR from separately digitized printed volumes. The linked scan pages are research locators; their images have not been collated for this note's flagged readings. OCR agreement does not verify Greek or Hebrew letters, diacritics, word order, or table layout. The flagged readings or layout remain uncertain. CLA_DEU.PDF, PDF page 87; Additional printed-scan page locator (OCR context only; flagged reading unverified).

Verse 17. But thou shalt utterly destroy them] The above reasoning will gain considerable strength, provided we could translate כי החרם תחרימם hi hacharem tacharimem, thou shalt utterly subdue them-slaying them if they resist, and thus leaving nothing alive that breathed; or totally expel them from the land, or reduce them to a state of slavery in it, that they might no longer exist as a people. This certainly made them an anathema as a nation, wholly destroying their political existence. Probably this was so understood by the Gibeonites, viz., that they either must be slain or utterly leave the land, which last was certainly in their power, and therefore, by a stratagem, they got the princes of Israel to make a league with them. When the deceit was discovered, the Israelites, though not bound by their oath, because they were deceived by the Gibeonites, and therefore were under no obligation to fulfil their part of the covenant; yet, though they had this command before their eyes, did not believe that they were bound to put even those deceivers to death; but they destroyed their political existence, by making them hewers of wood and drawers of water to the congregation; i.e., slaves to the Israelites. (See Joshua 9:23) Rahab and her household also were spared. So that it does not appear that the Israelites believed that they were bound to put every Canaanite to death. Their political existence was under the anathema, and this the Hebrews annihilated.

That many of the Canaanites continued in the land even to the days of Solomon, we have the fullest proof; for we read, 2 Chronicles 8:7: “All the people of the land that were left of the Hittites, Amorites, Perizzites, Hivites, and Jebusites, who were left in the land, whom the children of Israel consumed not, them did Solomon make to pay tribute to this day.” Thus Solomon destroyed their political existence, but did not consider himself bound by the law of God to put them to death.

Cited across the library (1 reference)
18

That they teach you not to do after all their abominations, which they have done unto their gods; so should ye sin against the LORD your God.

Joseph Benson on Deuteronomy 20:18
Joseph Benson's Commentary · source PDF p. 782

Verse 18. That they teach you not to do after all their abominations — Here is the great reason for the aforesaid severe execution; they were most abominable idolaters, who offered their children to Moloch; they were magicians, wizards, necromancers, and guilty of all those abominations and filthy lusts mentioned Leviticus 18. So that God thought them not fit to live any longer upon the face of the earth; for had they been spared, after obstinately rejecting terms of peace, they would undoubtedly have sought to infect the Israelites with their filthy idolatry; and it was mercy to the human race in general not to suffer such a wicked, contagious generation to subsist. From the words here quoted, That they teach you not, &c., a Jewish writer justly observes, “If they repented and forsook their idolatry, the Israelites might let them live;” for then there was no such danger in sparing them. Accordingly Rahab, her father, mother, brethren, and all her kindred, were preserved alive, and so were the Hivites or Gibeonites, on condition of servitude, which they themselves offered, Joshua 9:11-15. See Joshua 11:11-20; Jeremiah 18:7, 8.

19

When thou shalt besiege a city a long time, in making war against it to take it, thou shalt not destroy the trees thereof by forcing an axe against them: for thou mayest eat of them, and thou shalt not cut them down (for the tree of the field is man’s life) to employ them in the siege:

John Wesley on Deuteronomy 20:19
John Wesley's Explanatory Notes · source PDF p. 577

V. 19. Thou shalt not destroy-Which is to be understood of a general destruction of them, not of the cutting down some few of them, as the conveniency of the siege might require. Man’s life-The sustenance or support of his life.

Adam Clarke on Deuteronomy 20:19
Clarke's Commentary · source PDF p. 88

Editorial note: Source collation note — paragraph 1: “has been variously translated, כי האדם עץ השׂדה לבא מפניך במצור ki haadam ets”. source PDF page 88: “has been variously translated, מפניך לבא השׂדה עצ האדם כי במצור ki haadam ets hassadeh”. Compared with CLA_DEU.PDF PDF p. 88. The source-font or layout comparison does not securely establish every letter, mark or local sequence in these passages. The flagged language readings or layout are retained; the original source pages should be consulted for these specific readings. Additional-source investigation: an automated comparison of surrounding English text located possible corresponding passages in OCR from separately digitized printed volumes. The linked scan pages are research locators; their images have not been collated for this note's flagged readings. OCR agreement does not verify Greek or Hebrew letters, diacritics, word order, or table layout. The flagged readings or layout remain uncertain. CLA_DEU.PDF, PDF page 88; Additional printed-scan page locator (OCR context only; flagged reading unverified).

Verse 19. (For the tree of the field is man’s life) to employ them in the siege] The original is exceedingly obscure, and has been variously translated, כי האדם עץ השׂדה לבא מפניך במצור ki haadam ets

hassadeh labo mippaneycha bammatsor. The following are the chief versions: For, O man, the trees of the field are for thee to employ THEM in the siege-or, For it is man, and the tree of the field, that must go before thee for a bulwark-or, For it is a tree, and not men, to increase the number of those who come against thee to the siege-or, lastly, The tree of the field (is as) a man, to go before thy face for a bulwark. The sense is sufficiently clear, though the strict grammatical meaning of the words cannot be easily ascertained: it was a merciful provision to spare all fruit-bearing trees, because they yielded the fruit which supported man’s life; and it was sound policy also, for even the conquerors must perish if the means of life were cut off.

It is diabolic cruelty to add to the miseries of war the horrors of famine; and this is done where the trees of the field are cut down, the dykes broken to drown the land, the villages burnt, and the crops wilfully spoiled. O execrable war! subversive of all the charities of life!

THERE are several curious particulars in these verses: 1. The people had the most positive assurances from God that their enemies should not be able to prevail against them by strength, numbers, nor stratagem, because God should go with them to lead and direct them, and should fight for them; and against his might none could prevail. 2. All such interferences were standing proofs of the being of God, of his especial providence, and of the truth of their religion. 3. Though God promised them such protection, yet they were to expect it in the diligent use of their own prudence and industry. The priests, the officers, and the people, had their respective parts to act in this business; if they did their duty respectively, God would take care that they should be successful. Those who will not help themselves with the strength which God has already given them, shall not have any farther assistance from him. In all such cases, the parable of the talents affords an accurate rule. 4. Their going to war against their enemies must not deprive them of mercy and tenderness towards their brethren. He who had built a house and had not yet dwelt in it, who had planted a vineyard and had not eaten of its fruits, who had betrothed a wife and had not yet taken her to his house, was not obliged to go to battle, lest he should fall in the war, and the fruits of his industry and affection be enjoyed by others. He who was faint-hearted was also permitted to return, lest he should give way in the heat of battle, and his example have a fatal influence on others. DEUTERONOMY

Joseph Benson on Deuteronomy 20:19
Joseph Benson's Commentary · source PDF p. 783

Verse 19. Thou shalt not destroy the trees — Which is to be understood of a general destruction of them, not of cutting down some few of them, as the convenience of the siege might require. Man’s life — The sustenance or support of his life.

Joseph Sutcliffe on Deuteronomy 20:19
Joseph Sutcliffe's Commentary · source PDF p. 503

Ver. 19. The tree of the field is man’s life, and must not be destroyed. Alexander the Great restrained his army from hurting trees and houses by saying, they are your own property.

Daniel Whedon on Deuteronomy 20:19
Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testament · source PDF p. 638

19. Not destroy the trees — In the besieging of cities there was to be no wanton destruction of property. The fruit trees in the gardens of the environs were not to be cut down. War, as anciently carried on, was terrible. Life and property, except so far as they could be of service to the conqueror, were to be destroyed. Moses, with these stern laws prevalent, aims to introduce a gentler and more lenient usage into the military code. For the tree… is man’s life — The Hebrew expression is difficult of translation. Ewald, Knobel, Keil, and others render it as a question, Is the tree of the field a man, that it come in siege before thee? But this translation, which follows the Septuagint, requires a different pointing of the Hebrew text. The literal rendering of the passage is, Man is the tree of the field — that is, he lives and is supported by the fruits of trees. Our Authorized Version gives the substantial sense.

20

Only the trees which thou knowest that they be not trees for meat, thou shalt destroy and cut them down; and thou shalt build bulwarks against the city that maketh war with thee, until it be subdued.

Daniel Whedon on Deuteronomy 20:20
Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testament · source PDF p. 639

20. Not trees for meat — This verse suggests such acquaintance with laying siege to fortified places as might have been learned from the Egyptians.

Closing reflections and analysis

Joseph Sutcliffe

REFLECTIONS.

The encouragement afforded to Israel, in this chapter, is equally encouraging to the church of God. They were not to be afraid of their enemies who should exceed them in number, in chariots, and in horses; for the covenant presence of God would ensure success. So if the Lord be for us, what have we to fear from the multitude of our foes? The frowns and smiles of the world, the incitements of the flesh, and the temptations of Satan shall try us in vain, while we retain the Lord on our right hand. The Israelites, having God for their defence, had no need of severity in raising the levies of war. The heralds, on addressing the army, were to request those to retire who had built a house, and not consecrated it; who had betrothed a wife, as we elsewhere find, and not consummated the marriage; or had planted a vineyard, and had not eaten of its fruits. The fearful and fainthearted were next requested to withdraw; for the man who had not a martial soul was not fit to be intrusted with the defence of his country. In those heralds, ministers of the gospel may learn the duty of exhorting believers to courage and constancy in religion. Let those who love house or land, wife or children more than Christ, keep within the shade of worldly prudence. The man who is not willing, through the strength of grace, to devote his life to God, is not worthy to bear the banner of the cross, and to be intrusted with the honour and glory of the Saviour’s cause.

The nation or host assembled in arms, was next to be enlightened concerning the equity of the war; for God is on the side of equity. A nation may indeed allege equity in the cause of war, and yet be deeply guilty in other views; or it may be the design of providence to suffer a weak people to be for awhile oppressed by the mighty. Be that as it may, those who commence a war should be cautious that their claims are just, and that all amicable endeavours to adjust the disputes have failed before recourse is had to arms. War must in all cases be the dernier resort, or it is hateful to God.

However aggravating the aggressions may be which provoke a nation to vengeance, the war must nevertheless be conducted with humanity. The city when approached must be summoned to surrender: then if the armed men preferred a siege to submission, the contest became life for life: and if the city was taken by assault, the casting away of arms, the bending of knees, the most piercing cries for mercy would have no effect on the furious assailants: they would put them all to the sword, and spare only the women and children. Such are the bitter laws of war, when the contest comes to extremities. In like manner, all daring sinners who despise the overtures of grace, may see the sad situation to which they will shortly be reduced. While they are proceeding in a course of dissipation and insolence against heaven, the God of vengeance approaches, and death is in his train. But his ministers first blow the gospel trumpet; they expostulate; they offer pardon and privilege; they pray and beseech the enemy in Christ’s stead to be reconciled to God. But all overtures of grace are rejected, religion is hooted, and the terrors of justice are despised. Alas, only a small number listen to the gospel, and imbibe its spirit. Well, God is neither weak in power, nor intimidated by the multitude of his foes. He resolutely besieges the wicked by terror of conscience, by affliction of body, and the menaces of future judgment; and if the longsuffering of God which leadeth to repentance be still despised, his arrows shall strike through the heart of his enemies; and because they despised his counsel, and would have none of his reproof, he also will laugh at their calamity, and mock when their fear cometh. Then, in a spiritual view, shall be realized the horrors of a city taken by assault. God will avenge the quarrel of his covenant, and the dissipation of an ungodly age shall end in tragedy of the most instructive kind.