WesleyanHeritage Library Search
Menu
Judges · 30 verses

Judges 19

Read slowly. Let the words lead you to Christ.

Chapter introductions

John Wesley

CHAPTER 19.

The adultery of the Levite’s concubine, ver. 1, 2. The reconciliation to her, and entertainment at her father’s, ver. 3-9. His journey homeward as far as Gibeah, ver. 10-15. An Ephraimite takes him in, ver. 16-21. The men of Gibeah assault the house, ver. 22-24. They force his concubine to death, ver. 25-28. He sends notice of it to all the tribes of Israel, ver. 29, 30

Adam Clarke

CHAPTER 19

A Levite and his concubine disagree; and she leaves him and goes to her father’s house, 1, 2. He follows to bring her back, and is kindly entertained by her father five days, 3-8. He returns; and lodges the first night at Gibeah, in the tribe of Benjamin, 9-21. The men of Gibeah attack the house, and insist on abusing the body of the Levite; who, to save himself, delivers to them his concubine, whose life falls a victim to their brutality, 22-27. The Levite divides her dead body into twelve pieces, and sends one to each of the twelve tribes; they are struck with horror, and call a council on the subject, 28-30. NOTES ON CHAP. 19

Joseph Benson

CHAPTER 19.

A.M. 2598. — B.C. 1406.

The adultery of the Levite’s concubine, 1, 2. His reconciliation to her, and entertainment at her father’s, 3-9. His journey homeward as far as Gibeah, 10-15. An Ephraimite takes him in, 16-21. The men of Gibeah assault the house, 22-24. They force his concubine to death, 25-28. He sends notice of it to all the tribes of Israel, 29, 30.

NOTES ON CHAPTER 19.

Joseph Sutcliffe

CHAPTER 19.

Daniel Whedon

CHAPTER 19.

1

And it came to pass in those days, when there was no king in Israel, that there was a certain Levite sojourning on the side of mount Ephraim, who took to him a concubine out of Bethlehemjudah.

John Wesley on Judges 19:1
John Wesley's Explanatory Notes · source PDF p. 777

V. 1. A. concubine-Heb. a wife, a concubine, that is, such a concubine as was also his wife: called a concubine, only because she was not endowed. Perhaps he had nothing to endow her with, being himself only a sojourner.

Adam Clarke on Judges 19:1
Clarke's Commentary · source PDF p. 156

Verse 1. There was no king in Israel] All sorts of disorders are attributed to the want of civil government; justice, right, truth, and humanity, had fallen in the streets.

Took to him a concubine] We have already seen that the concubine was a sort of secondary wife; and that such connections were not disreputable, being according to the general custom of those times. The word פילגש pilegesh, concubine, is supposed by Mr. Parkhurst to be compounded of פלג palag, “to divide, or share;” and נגש nagash, “to approach;” because the husband shared or divided his attention and affections between her and the real wife; from whom she differed in nothing material, except in her posterity not inheriting.

Joseph Benson on Judges 19:1
Joseph Benson's Commentary · source PDF p. 111

Verse 1. Who took him a concubine — Hebrew, a wife, a concubine, that is, such a concubine as was also his wife: called a concubine only because she was not endowed. Perhaps he had nothing to endow her with, being himself only a sojourner. “Women of this sort differed little from the wife, except in some outward ceremonies and stipulations, but agreed with her in all the true essentials of marriage, and gave themselves up to the husband, (for so he is called in the next chapter, verse 4,) with faith plighted, and with affection.” — Dr. Dodd, who refers to Sterne’s Sermons, vol. 3. Ser. 3., and Selden de Jure, Nat. lib. 5. c. 7.

Joseph Sutcliffe on Judges 19:1
Joseph Sutcliffe's Commentary · source PDF p. 665

Verse 1. In those days, while Phinehas was highpriest, and in the first generation after Joshua’s death. He is called her husband, ver. 3; and it was adultery for a woman so espoused to connect herself with another man.

Daniel Whedon on Judges 19:1–30
Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testament · source PDF p. 368

THE LEVITE AND HIS CONCUBINE, 1-30.

1. In those days — When Phinehas, the grandson of Aaron, was high priest, (Judges 20:28;) consequently, not long after the days of Joshua. Sojourning on… mount Ephraim — So that he was in the same vicinity where Micah dwelt. Judges 17:1. A concubine — A wife of second rank, who had no other rights than those of cohabitation and subsistence, and even then the husband could send her away with a small present, as Abraham did Hagar. Genesis 21:14. The practice is condemned by New Testament ethics, but by this standard we are not to judge the examples of Nahor, (Genesis 22:24,) Abraham, (Genesis 25:6,) Jacob, (Genesis 30:3; 35:22,) and other of the Old Testament worthies. The Law of Moses made provision for concubinage; but even its regulations touching man and wife were set aside by our Lord, and treated as a politic measure, in view of the hardness of the people’s hearts. Matthew 19:8.

2

And his concubine played the whore against him, and went away from him unto her father’s house to Bethlehemjudah, and was there four whole months.

John Wesley on Judges 19:2
John Wesley's Explanatory Notes · source PDF p. 777

V. 2. Against him-That is, against her faith given to him. Went away-Either for fear of punishment; or, because her heart was alienated from him; wherein not only she sinned, but her father by connivance at her sin, and neglect of just endeavours for her reconciliation to her husband.

Adam Clarke on Judges 19:2
Clarke's Commentary · source PDF p. 156

Editorial note: Source collation note — paragraph 1: “with him; the targum ובסרת עלוהי ubserath alohi, that she”. source PDF page 156: “with him; the Targum עלוהי ובסרת ubserath alohi that she”. Compared with CLA_JDG.PDF PDF p. 156. The source-font or layout comparison does not securely establish every letter, mark or local sequence in these passages. The flagged language readings or layout are retained; the original source pages should be consulted for these specific readings. Additional-source investigation: an automated comparison of surrounding English text located possible corresponding passages in OCR from separately digitized printed volumes. The linked scan pages are research locators; their images have not been collated for this note's flagged readings. OCR agreement does not verify Greek or Hebrew letters, diacritics, word order, or table layout. The flagged readings or layout remain uncertain. CLA_JDG.PDF, PDF page 156; Additional printed-scan page locator (OCR context only; flagged reading unverified).

Verse 2. Played the whore] Neither the Vulgate, Septuagint, Targum, nor Josephus, understand this word as implying any act of conjugal infidelity on the woman’s part. They merely state that the parties disagreed, and the woman returned to her father’s house. Indeed all the circumstances of the case vindicate this view of the subject. If she had been a whore, or adulteress, it is not very likely that her husband would have gone after her to speak friendly, literally, to speak to her heart, and entreat her to return. The Vulgate simply states, quæ reliquit eum, that she left him; the Septuagint, ωργισθη αυτω, that she was angry with him; the Targum ובסרת עלוהי ubserath alohi, that she despised him; Josephus, αλλοτοιως ειχε, that she was alienated, or separated herself, from him. Houbigant translates the clause: quæ cum ab eo alienata esset, vel irata in eum esset, eum reliquit; “who when she was alienated from him, or angry with him, left him;” and he defends this version in his note. I think the true meaning to be among the above interpretations. They had contentions; she ceased to love him, her affections were alienated from him; and she left his house, and went home to her father.

Joseph Benson on Judges 19:2–3
Joseph Benson's Commentary · source PDF p. 111

Verses 2, 3. Played the whore against him — Against her faith given to him. Went away — Either for fear of punishment, or because her heart was alienated from him; wherein not only she sinned, but her father, by connivance at her sin, and neglect of just endeavours for her reconciliation to her husband. Her husband went to speak friendly unto her — To offer her pardon and reconciliation.

Joseph Sutcliffe on Judges 19:2
Joseph Sutcliffe's Commentary · source PDF p. 665

Ver. 2. His concubine played the whore. The LXX read, “was angry with him.” The Chaldaic reads, “despised him.”

Daniel Whedon on Judges 19:2
Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testament · source PDF p. 368

2. Played the whore — Dr. Clarke, on the authority of Josephus and several of the ancient versions, understands that they had contentions, and, being alienated in her affections from her husband, she ran away, and went home to her father’s house; but the Hebrew word here used ever means a criminal act of conjugal infidelity.

Cited across the library (1 reference)
3

And her husband arose, and went after her, to speak friendly unto her, and to bring her again, having his servant with him, and a couple of asses: and she brought him into her father’s house: and when the father of the damsel saw him, he rejoiced to meet him.

John Wesley on Judges 19:3
John Wesley's Explanatory Notes · source PDF p. 777

V. 3. Friendly-To offer her pardon and reconciliation.

Adam Clarke on Judges 19:3
Clarke's Commentary · source PDF p. 157

Verse 3. He rejoiced to meet him.] He hoped to be able completely to reconcile his daughter and her husband.

Daniel Whedon on Judges 19:3
Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testament · source PDF p. 368

3. To speak friendly unto her — Literally, to speak to her heart. “To conciliate her affection, to rekindle her tenderness, to whisper forgiveness to her, and to implore her to return to the home she had left desolate. He had, perhaps, heard that she was penitent; for the phrase often denotes the giving of comfort to one who is in sorrow.” — Kitto. Rejoiced to meet him — To meet him on such an errand, for he might have come not to speak friendly to her, but to scourge her for her crime of conjugal infidelity. Leviticus 19:20.

4

And his father in law, the damsel’s father, retained him; and he abode with him three days: so they did eat and drink, and lodged there.

5

And it came to pass on the fourth day, when they arose early in the morning, that he rose up to depart: and the damsel’s father said unto his son in law, Comfort thine heart with a morsel of bread, and afterward go your way.

6

And they sat down, and did eat and drink both of them together: for the damsel’s father had said unto the man, Be content, I pray thee, and tarry all night, and let thine heart be merry.

7

And when the man rose up to depart, his father in law urged him: therefore he lodged there again.

8

And he arose early in the morning on the fifth day to depart; and the damsel’s father said, Comfort thine heart, I pray thee. And they tarried until afternoon, and they did eat both of them.

Adam Clarke on Judges 19:8
Clarke's Commentary · source PDF p. 157

Verse 8. And they tarried until afternoon] Merely that they might avoid the heat of the day, which would have been very inconvenient in travelling.

Daniel Whedon on Judges 19:8
Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testament · source PDF p. 368

8. Until afternoon — Literally, until the declining of the day. “All the painful results grew out of this detention and late setting out, and may help, if every day did not supply lessons enough, to teach us the danger and weakness of allowing our better judgment to be overcome by even the kind importunities of others.” — Kitto.

9

And when the man rose up to depart, he, and his concubine, and his servant, his father in law, the damsel’s father, said unto him, Behold, now the day draweth toward evening, I pray you tarry all night: behold, the day groweth to an end, lodge here, that thine heart may be merry; and to morrow get you early on your way, that thou mayest go home.

Adam Clarke on Judges 19:9
Clarke's Commentary · source PDF p. 157

Editorial note: Source collation note — paragraph 1: “groweth to an end] חנות היום chanoth haiyom, “the day”. source PDF page 157: “groweth to an end היום חנות chanoth haiyom “the day”. Compared with CLA_JDG.PDF PDF p. 157. The source-font or layout comparison does not securely establish every letter, mark or local sequence in these passages. The flagged language readings or layout are retained; the original source pages should be consulted for these specific readings. Additional-source investigation: an automated comparison of surrounding English text located possible corresponding passages in OCR from separately digitized printed volumes. The linked scan pages are research locators; their images have not been collated for this note's flagged readings. OCR agreement does not verify Greek or Hebrew letters, diacritics, word order, or table layout. The flagged readings or layout remain uncertain. CLA_JDG.PDF, PDF page 157; Additional printed-scan page locator (OCR context only; flagged reading unverified).

Verse 9. The day groweth to an end] חנות היום chanoth haiyom, “the day is about to pitch its tent;” that is, it was near the time in which travellers ordinarily pitched their tents, to take up their lodging for the night.

10

But the man would not tarry that night, but he rose up and departed, and came over against Jebus, which is Jerusalem; and there were with him two asses saddled, his concubine also was with him.

Daniel Whedon on Judges 19:10
Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testament · source PDF p. 369

10. Jebus — The ancient name of Jerusalem. See at Joshua 15:63, and chap. 1:21. This was a journey of about two hours north of Beth-lehem.

11

And when they were by Jebus, the day was far spent; and the servant said unto his master, Come, I pray thee, and let us turn in into this city of the Jebusites, and lodge in it.

Adam Clarke on Judges 19:11
Clarke's Commentary · source PDF p. 157

Verse 11. When they were by Jebus] This was Jerusalem, in which, though after the death of Joshua it appears to have been partly conquered by the tribe of Judah, yet the Jebusites kept the strong hold of Zion till the days of David, by whom they were finally expelled. See Clarke’s note on “Judges 1:8”.

Joseph Sutcliffe on Judges 19:11
Joseph Sutcliffe's Commentary · source PDF p. 665

Ver. 11. When they were by Jebus; that is, Jerusalem; shalom was added to Jebus, it would seem, in memory of its peace. Joshua had taken the lower town; but the city or fortress called Zion, after the ark rested there, he could not take. 2 Samuel 5:7, 9.

12

And his master said unto him, We will not turn aside hither into the city of a stranger, that is not of the children of Israel; we will pass over to Gibeah.

John Wesley on Judges 19:12
John Wesley's Explanatory Notes · source PDF p. 777

V. 12. A stranger-That is, of a strange nation: which the Canaanites possess; for though the city Jerusalem had been taken by Caleb, Judges 1:8, yet the strong fort of Zion was still in their hands, whence it is likely they did much molest, and afterwards by God’s permission, drive out the Israelites who dwelt there.

Joseph Benson on Judges 19:12
Joseph Benson's Commentary · source PDF p. 111

Verse 12. The city of a stranger — That is, of a strange nation; a city which the Canaanites possess. For though Jerusalem had been taken by Caleb, (chap. 1.,) yet the strong fort of Zion was still in their hands, whence it is likely they did much molest, and afterward, by God’s permission, drive out the Israelites who dwelt there.

13

And he said unto his servant, Come, and let us draw near to one of these places to lodge all night, in Gibeah, or in Ramah.

Daniel Whedon on Judges 19:13
Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testament · source PDF p. 369

13. In Gibeah, or in Ramah — Cities of Benjamin lying northward from Jerusalem, one about an hour, the other two hours, or more, distant. See Joshua 18:25, 28.

14

And they passed on and went their way; and the sun went down upon them when they were by Gibeah, which belongeth to Benjamin.

15

And they turned aside thither, to go in and to lodge in Gibeah: and when he went in, he sat him down in a street of the city: for there was no man that took them into his house to lodging.

John Wesley on Judges 19:15
John Wesley's Explanatory Notes · source PDF p. 777

V. 15. To lodge-Though they were soft and effeminate in other respects, yet they were hard-hearted to strangers, and at that time there were no public-houses in that country.

Adam Clarke on Judges 19:15
Clarke's Commentary · source PDF p. 157

Verse 15. No man-took them into his house to lodging.] There was probably no inn or house of public entertainment in this place, and therefore they could not have a lodging unless furnished by mere hospitality. To say that there were no inns in those primitive times, is not true; there were such places, though not very frequent. Joseph’s brethren found their money in their sacks when they loosed them at an inn, Genesis 42:27. The house of Rahab was an inn, Joshua 2:1. And the woman whose house Samson frequented at Gaza was a hostess, or one who kept a place of public entertainment.

Joseph Benson on Judges 19:15
Joseph Benson's Commentary · source PDF p. 111

Verse 15. He sat down in the street of the city — There being no public inns in that country in those days, this was the general custom. Travellers sat down in the streets till some person invited them into his house. And this was generally readily done by one or other, except in places where there was a great degeneracy of manners. Here, although they were soft and effeminate in other respects, yet they were hard-hearted to strangers, for there was no man that took them into his house to lodging, till a poor labouring man performed that office of hospitality toward them.

Daniel Whedon on Judges 19:15
Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testament · source PDF p. 369

15. He sat him down in a street of the city — This, we are told by Orientalists, is a way of making known one’s want of entertainment, and is a custom still existing in the East. Usually one is allowed to wait but a little while in such a place. For there was no man that took them — Rather, And no man took them. This implies that the inhabitants of that town were wilfully inhospitable. It was a reproach to them that they allowed a wayfaring man to wait so long in a street of their city before entertainment was offered him, and verse 18 implies that the Levite himself felt misused.

16

And, behold, there came an old man from his work out of the field at even, which was also of mount Ephraim; and he sojourned in Gibeah: but the men of the place were Benjamites.

John Wesley on Judges 19:16
John Wesley's Explanatory Notes · source PDF p. 777

V. 16. Ephraim-Whence also the Levite was, which enclined him to shew the more kindness to his country-man. Benjamites-This was indeed one of the cities belonging to the priests; but the cities which were given to the priests, and whereof they were owners, were not inhabited by the priests or Levites only, especially at this time when they were but few in number, but by many other persons of different professions.

Joseph Benson on Judges 19:16
Joseph Benson's Commentary · source PDF p. 112

Verse 16. Also of mount Ephraim — Whence likewise the Levite was, which inclined him to show the more kindness to his countryman. But the men of the place were Benjamites — This was indeed one of the cities belonging to the priests; but the cities which were given to the priests, and whereof they were owners, were not inhabited by the priests or Levites only, especially at this time, when they were but few in number, but by many other persons of different professions.

17

And when he had lifted up his eyes, he saw a wayfaring man in the street of the city: and the old man said, Whither goest thou? and whence comest thou?

18

And he said unto him, We are passing from Bethlehemjudah toward the side of mount Ephraim; from thence am I: and I went to Bethlehemjudah, but I am now going to the house of the LORD; and there is no man that receiveth me to house.

John Wesley on Judges 19:18
John Wesley's Explanatory Notes · source PDF p. 777

V. 18. House of the Lord-Which was in Shiloh. Thither he went, either because he lived there, for that was in the tribe of Ephraim; or, rather, because he would there offer prayers and praises, and sacrifices to God, for his mercy in reconciling him and his wife.

Joseph Benson on Judges 19:18
Joseph Benson's Commentary · source PDF p. 112

Verse 18. House of the Lord — Which was in Shiloh. Thither he went, either because he lived there for that was in the tribe of Ephraim; or, rather, because he would there offer prayers and praises, and sacrifices to God, for his mercy in reconciling him and his wife.

Joseph Sutcliffe on Judges 19:18
Joseph Sutcliffe's Commentary · source PDF p. 665

Ver. 18. No man receiveth me. Benjamites without hospitality, without law, without religion! Habits of life which lead to awful issues. This however was a local sin; Israel, as a nation, abhorred the deed.

19

Yet there is both straw and provender for our asses; and there is bread and wine also for me, and for thy handmaid, and for the young man which is with thy servants: there is no want of any thing.

Adam Clarke on Judges 19:19
Clarke's Commentary · source PDF p. 157

Verse 19. There is both straw and provender for our asses.] In the countries principally devoted to pasturage, there was no hay; but as they raised some corn, they took great care of their straw, chopped it very small, and having mixed it with barley, beans, or the pounded kernels of dates, made it into balls, and fed their cattle with it. Straw, cut into what is called chaff, is not unfrequently used in England for the same purpose.

Joseph Benson on Judges 19:19
Joseph Benson's Commentary · source PDF p. 112

Verse 19. Yet there is both straw, &c. — The Levite here acquaints the man that he had with him all things necessary both for himself and his concubine, his servant and his asses; so that he should not burden any man who should receive him, as he only wanted some place to lodge in. For thy handmaid — Or, as we should speak now, for the woman that is with me. The young man that is with thy servants — Or along with us. It was a form of expression in those days to entitle themselves the servants of those they spoke to with any degree of respect.

Daniel Whedon on Judges 19:19
Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testament · source PDF p. 369

19. Straw… provender… bread… wine — “This shows that the Israelites did then, as the Orientals do now, take with them the provisions for themselves and beasts that they required during a journey, replenishing their stores from time to time when they came to a town that could supply them. The straw was chopped straw, used in the East instead of hay; and the provender barley. This is carried in hair bags, something like the mouth-bags of our horses, but of larger size.” — Kitto.

20

And the old man said, Peace be with thee; howsoever let all thy wants lie upon me; only lodge not in the street.

John Wesley on Judges 19:20
John Wesley's Explanatory Notes · source PDF p. 778

V. 20. Let all, &c.-It matters not whether thou wantest nothing or everything, I will take care to supply all thy wants.

Adam Clarke on Judges 19:20
Clarke's Commentary · source PDF p. 157

Verse 20. All thy wants lie upon me] Here was genuine hospitality: “Keep your bread and wine for yourselves, and your straw and provender for your asses; you may need them before you finish your journey; I will supply all your wants for this night, therefore do not lodge in the street.”

Joseph Benson on Judges 19:20–21
Joseph Benson's Commentary · source PDF p. 112

Verses 20, 21. Let all thy wants lie upon me — It matters not whether thou wantest nothing or every thing; I will take care to supply all thy wants. They washed their feet — As they used to do to travellers in those hot countries.

Cited across the library (1 reference)
21

So he brought him into his house, and gave provender unto the asses: and they washed their feet, and did eat and drink.

John Wesley on Judges 19:21
John Wesley's Explanatory Notes · source PDF p. 778

V. 21. Washed-As they used to do to travellers in those hot countries.

Daniel Whedon on Judges 19:21
Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testament · source PDF p. 369

21. Washed their feet — One of the most ancient usages of Eastern hospitality, (Genesis 18:4; 19. 2,) being regarded as a mark of respect to a guest, and of kind attention on the part of the host.

22

Now as they were making their hearts merry, behold, the men of the city, certain sons of Belial, beset the house round about, and beat at the door, and spake to the master of the house, the old man, saying, Bring forth the man that came into thine house, that we may know him.

John Wesley on Judges 19:22
John Wesley's Explanatory Notes · source PDF p. 778

V. 22. Merry-That is, refreshing themselves with the provisions set before them. Sons of belial-Children of the devil, wicked and licentious men.

Adam Clarke on Judges 19:22
Clarke's Commentary · source PDF p. 158

Verse 22. Sons of Belial] Profligate fellows. See Clarke’s notes on “Deuteronomy 13:13”.

That we may know him.] See Genesis 19:5. These were genuine sodomites as to their practice; sons of Belial, rascals and miscreants of the deepest dye; worse than brutes, being a compound of beast and devil inseparably blended.

Joseph Benson on Judges 19:22–23
Joseph Benson's Commentary · source PDF p. 112

Verses 22, 23. As they were making their hearts merry — That is, refreshing themselves with the provisions set before them. Behold, certain sons of Belial — Children of the devil, wicked and licentious men. Bring forth the man, &c. — They wanted the Levite brought forth, that they might satisfy their unnatural lusts. This man is come into my house — And therefore I am obliged to protect him by the laws of hospitality. As several circumstances of this horrid wickedness resemble those of the affair recorded Genesis 19., we refer the reader to the notes on that chapter.

Joseph Sutcliffe on Judges 19:22
Joseph Sutcliffe's Commentary · source PDF p. 665

Ver. 22. Sons of Belial. Lawless men. Deuteronomy 13:13.

Daniel Whedon on Judges 19:22
Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testament · source PDF p. 369

22. Making their hearts merry — By eating, drinking, and conversation. This indicates the warmth and cheer of ancient friendship and hospitality. Sons of Belial — Low, lewd, worthless fellows, such as their conduct showed them to be. See note on 1 Samuel 1:16. Bring forth the man — Most shameful and impudent demand, the revived voice of wicked Sodom. Compare Genesis 19:1-11. That we may know him — “These,” says Clarke, “were genuine Sodomites as to their practice; rascals and miscreants of the deepest dye; worse than brutes, being a compound of beast and devil inseparably blended.”

Cited across the library (2 references)
23

And the man, the master of the house, went out unto them, and said unto them, Nay, my brethren, nay, I pray you, do not so wickedly; seeing that this man is come into mine house, do not this folly.

John Wesley on Judges 19:23
John Wesley's Explanatory Notes · source PDF p. 778

V. 23. Into my house-And therefore I am obliged to protect him by the laws of hospitality.

24

Behold, here is my daughter a maiden, and his concubine; them I will bring out now, and humble ye them, and do with them what seemeth good unto you: but unto this man do not so vile a thing.

Adam Clarke on Judges 19:24
Clarke's Commentary · source PDF p. 158

Verse 24. Here is my daughter, a maiden] Such a proposal was made by Lot to the men of Sodom, Genesis 19:8, but nothing can excuse either. That the rights of hospitality were sacred in the East, and most highly regarded we know; and that a man would defend, at the expense of his life, the stranger whom he had admitted under his roof, is true; but how a father could make such a proposal relative to his virgin daughter, must remain among those things which are incomprehensible.

Joseph Benson on Judges 19:24
Joseph Benson's Commentary · source PDF p. 112

Verse 24. Behold, here is my daughter, &c. — The master of the house came at last to a resolution that it was less wickedness to prostitute the women to their lusts than the Levite. The dilemma to which he was reduced was indeed dreadful, nevertheless he is not to be justified in the proposal which he makes, no more than Lot was to be justified in a similar case, in offering his two daughters to satisfy the lusts of the men of Sodom. Although of two evils we must choose the less, yet, as we have there observed, “of two sins we must choose neither, nor ever do evil that good may come.”

Joseph Sutcliffe on Judges 19:24
Joseph Sutcliffe's Commentary · source PDF p. 665

Ver. 24. My daughter, a maiden, said the poor man of mount Ephraim. An unoffending stranger is come under my sacred and absolute protection. Probably, like Lot, he had confidence that this overture would be rejected.

Daniel Whedon on Judges 19:24
Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testament · source PDF p. 369

24. Humble ye them — This was a proposition most shocking to our Christian instincts, but far less revolting, though not blameless, in that ancient time. It was a thing that had not occurred before in Israel. The fact here related shows how degraded was woman’s condition even in ancient Israel. She was regarded principally as the object meant for man to gratify his sensual lust upon, and held well nigh the position of a slave to him. But was it strange when, even now, in Japan and other lands, it is a common custom for parents to sell their daughters to persons to be subjected to lives of prostitution? A Christian lady, writing from Yokohama, Japan, in August, 1871, says: “In the suburbs of this city my friend pointed out to me a square of native houses in which, he told me, the licensed prostitution of the city is carried on. The victims are the fairest, choicest young girls of the place. They are sold by their parents, and the more beautiful they are, the higher price they command. From eight hundred to a thousand were confined in that square; and this is only what is found in every city in this land.”

25

But the men would not hearken to him: so the man took his concubine, and brought her forth unto them; and they knew her, and abused her all the night until the morning: and when the day began to spring, they let her go.

Adam Clarke on Judges 19:25
Clarke's Commentary · source PDF p. 158

Verse 25. So the man took his concubine] The word יחזק yachazek, which we here translate simply took, signifies rather to take or seize by violence. The woman would not go out to them; but her graceless husband forced her to go, in order that he might save his own body. He could have but little love for her, and this was the cause of their separation before. The men of Gibeah who wished to abuse the body of the Levite; the Levite who wished to save his body at the expense of the modesty, reputation, and life of his wife; and the old man who wished to save his guest at the expense of the violation of his daughter; are all characters that humanity and modesty wish to be buried in everlasting oblivion.

When the day began to spring] Their turpitude could not bear the full light of the day; and they dismissed the poor woman when the day began to break.

Joseph Sutcliffe on Judges 19:25
Joseph Sutcliffe's Commentary · source PDF p. 665

Ver. 25. So the man took his concubine, and brought her forth unto them. A base man, devoid of soul; ready and cunning enough to excite the tribes to war, but a real coward himself.

26

Then came the woman in the dawning of the day, and fell down at the door of the man’s house where her lord was, till it was light.

John Wesley on Judges 19:26
John Wesley's Explanatory Notes · source PDF p. 778

V. 26. Fell down-Namely, dead; killed partly with grief of heart, and partly with excessive abuse. Thus the sin she formerly chose, ver. 2, is now her destruction; and though her husband pardoned her, God would punish her, at least as to this life.

Adam Clarke on Judges 19:26
Clarke's Commentary · source PDF p. 158

Editorial note: Source collation note — paragraph 1: “words, judges 19:25: וידעו אותה ויתעללו בה כל הלילה vaiyedu othah, vaiyithallelu bah”. source PDF page 158: “words, Judges 19:25 בה ויתעללו אותה וידעו הלילה כל vaiyedu othah, vaiyithallelu bah”. Compared with CLA_JDG.PDF PDF p. 158. The source-font or layout comparison does not securely establish every letter, mark or local sequence in these passages. The flagged language readings or layout are retained; the original source pages should be consulted for these specific readings. Additional-source investigation: an automated comparison of surrounding English text located possible corresponding passages in OCR from separately digitized printed volumes. The linked scan pages are research locators; their images have not been collated for this note's flagged readings. OCR agreement does not verify Greek or Hebrew letters, diacritics, word order, or table layout. The flagged readings or layout remain uncertain. CLA_JDG.PDF, PDF page 158; Additional printed-scan page locator (OCR context only; flagged reading unverified).

Verse 26. Fell down at the door] She had strength to reach the door, but not to knock for admittance: when she reached the door she fell down dead! The reason of this abominable and horrid catastrophe is strongly signified by the original words, Judges 19:25: וידעו אותה ויתעללו בה כל הלילה vaiyedu othah, vaiyithallelu bah col hallailah, which we modestly translate, and they knew her, and they abused her all the night. More literally, but still not fully: Illi cum ea rem habuerunt, et alternatim in eam tota nocte ascenderunt. The hithpahel used here in the verb עלל greatly increases the sense: Conjugatio hithpahel frequentiam actus et immanem libidinem designat. The Arabic is not too strong; the following is its meaning: Exercuerunt in ea cupiditates suas, et mæchati, sunt in ea ad matutinum usque.

Joseph Benson on Judges 19:26
Joseph Benson's Commentary · source PDF p. 113

Verse 26. Then came the woman, and fell down, &c. — Namely, dead; killed partly with grief of heart, and partly with excessive abuse. Thus the sin she formerly chose, (verse 2,) is now her destruction; and though her husband pardoned her, God would punish her, at least as to this life.

27

And her lord rose up in the morning, and opened the doors of the house, and went out to go his way: and, behold, the woman his concubine was fallen down at the door of the house, and her hands were upon the threshold.

Joseph Benson on Judges 19:27–28
Joseph Benson's Commentary · source PDF p. 113

Verses 27, 28. Went out to go his way — Concluding, without doubt, that the Gibeathites had conveyed away his concubine, and would keep her, and therefore he hasted home to take proper measures for the recovery of her; as we find he did afterward to revenge her death. He said unto her, Up, and let us be going — He thought she was only asleep, and the unexpected surprise of seeing her, and his haste to get out of this inhospitable place, might make him express himself in this manner.

28

And he said unto her, Up, and let us be going. But none answered. Then the man took her up upon an ass, and the man rose up, and gat him unto his place.

29

And when he was come into his house, he took a knife, and laid hold on his concubine, and divided her, together with her bones, into twelve pieces, and sent her into all the coasts of Israel.

John Wesley on Judges 19:29
John Wesley's Explanatory Notes · source PDF p. 778

V. 29. Sent-By several messengers, with a relation of the fact.

Adam Clarke on Judges 19:29
Clarke's Commentary · source PDF p. 159

Verse 29. Divided her-into twelve pieces] There is no doubt that with the pieces he sent to each tribe a circumstantial account of the barbarity of the men of Gibeah; and it is very likely that they considered each of the pieces as expressing an execration, “If ye will not come and avenge my wrongs, may ye be hewn in pieces like this abused and murdered woman!” It was a custom among the ancient Highlanders in Scotland, when one clan wished to call all the rest to avenge its wrongs, to take a wooden cross, dip it in blood, and send it by a special messenger through all the clans. This was called the fire cross, because at sight of it each clan lighted a fire or beacon, which gave notice to all the adjoining clans that a general rising was immediately to take place.

Joseph Benson on Judges 19:29
Joseph Benson's Commentary · source PDF p. 113

Verse 29. He took a knife, &c. — As the Levite expected no justice from the elders of Gibeah, and there was no supreme head over all the tribes at that time, he had recourse to the elders of each respective tribe; and to move them the more, and stir them up to punish the offender, he sent a part of the body to each of them, preserved undoubtedly by some means from putrefaction. And, undoubtedly, he instructed those he sent with it to relate particularly the circumstances of the unparalleled and barbarous fact.

Joseph Sutcliffe on Judges 19:29
Joseph Sutcliffe's Commentary · source PDF p. 665

Ver. 29. Twelve pieces, which he sent first to Ephraim and Manasseh, and then to the ten tribes.

Daniel Whedon on Judges 19:29
Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testament · source PDF p. 370

29. Together with her bones — Rather, According to her bones, that is, severing her limbs, as he would those of an animal, according to the joints of the bones. Twelve pieces — One for each tribe in Israel. Compare Saul’s similar act in 1 Samuel 11:7. Sent her into all the coasts — The messengers who bore these pieces doubtless told the shocking story in all the coasts through which they passed.

Cited across the library (1 reference)
30

And it was so, that all that saw it said, There was no such deed done nor seen from the day that the children of Israel came up out of the land of Egypt unto this day: consider of it, take advice, and speak your minds.

John Wesley on Judges 19:30
John Wesley's Explanatory Notes · source PDF p. 778

V. 30. Speak-Let us meet together, and seriously consider, and every one freely speak what is to be done in this case.

Adam Clarke on Judges 19:30
Clarke's Commentary · source PDF p. 159

Verse 30. There was no such deed done nor seen] They were all struck with the enormity of the crime; and considered it a sovereign disgrace to all the tribes of Israel.

Consider of it] Literally, Put it to yourselves; take counsel upon it; and speak. This was the prelude to the council held, and the subsequent operations, which are mentioned in the following chapter. I HAVE passed over the abominable transactions of this chapter as lightly as I could, and shall make no apology to the learned or unlearned reader for leaving some things untranslated.

What a blessing are wholesome laws, and a vigorous and attentive magistracy! These wretched people had no form of government, and every one did what was right in his own eyes: their own eye (corrupt inclination) was the measure and rule of their conduct; and how bad a rule, the abuse and murder of the Levite’s wife testify. Reader, bless God for a civil government.

Joseph Benson on Judges 19:30
Joseph Benson's Commentary · source PDF p. 113

Verse 30. All said, There was no such deed done or seen, &c. — All who saw it, and heard the relation, were so moved with horror at it that they called upon each other to consult and give their opinion in what manner justice should be done upon the lewd and inhuman Gibeathites; as follows in the next chapter.

Daniel Whedon on Judges 19:30
Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testament · source PDF p. 370

30. No such deed done nor seen — It has its only parallel in the history of ancient Sodom, long before Israel’s exodus from the land of Egypt. Compare Genesis 19:1-11.

Closing reflections and analysis

Joseph Sutcliffe

REFLECTIONS.

For a wandering family the patriarchal government was happy in every view. We hear of no defects, no reign of crimes and vice in the camp of Abraham; but it was by no means adequate to the wants of municipal and national society. Therefore the Israelites experienced many inconveniences in the transition from one form of government to another. The Lord had indeed appointed extraordinary judges, besides the judgment of the Urim; but the spirit of jealousy and independence in the several tribes opposed their salutary operation, and often to the ruin of the country. This Levite, travelling in the evening instead of the morning, for he was detained by the unseasonable civilities of his father-in-law, shunned Jebus, to lodge in Gibeah; not knowing that the Jebusites were all saints in comparison of apostate Benjamin. Religion has indeed degenerated to an awful state, when it is safer to form connections of a relative or commercial nature with the people of the world, rather than with professors of religion. Benjamin’s depravity was discovered by the want of hospitality. No one sheltering this stranger, though he wanted nothing for himself, or for his beasts; that civility was reserved for a poor man of mount Ephraim, sojourning in Gibeah to earn his bread. Charity is truly the glory of religion; and when that is fled away, nothing but evil remains in the heart. The lewd and lawless sons of Belial, guilty of sodomy in their intentions, and of adultery and murder in their actions, give us a black portrait of the consummate wickedness to which the human heart may speedily attain. Probably one wretch more daring than the rest, first proposed the deed; and then the whole being already corrupt, instantly applaud the plan. A frantic tumultuous passion was excited, which was deaf to all argument, all cries, all entreaties. Instantly they rush into crimes which cannot be traced, which must not be named; crimes which heaven in mercy to the less guilty world, hides in the flames of hell, and conceals in volumes of eternal smoke. Ah, Israel: ah, Gibeah! Are these the children of fathers tutored of the Lord in the desert? Are these the descendants of men who had seen the wonderful works of the Lord, and sworn fidelity to his covenant? Is this the new generation, worse than the nations whom the Lord had nearly destroyed?—Jebusites, keep your purity, contract no marriages with Israel, make no covenants with a people not worthy of the human name; for how should you believe that God raised up this people to punish and exterminate your race? Come not near to their sanctuary, listen not to their law, believe not their history, for the glories of the desert are now enveloped in the darkness of eternal shame. Yea, such and worse are the hasty inferences of weak man, when a people are contemplated under a cloud of crime; and it really requires some time for the less instructed of the human kind to distinguish between the precious and the vile. The guilt however was not confined to the sons of Belial; the elders next morning by supineness, contaminated themselves, and the city also with all the crimes which the wicked had committed in the dark. They made no inquisition for blood. Every father was solicitous to save the honour and life of a son whom he ought to have disowned for ever. Here let magistrates, masters, and parents be instructed. Here is a tragic school, a black case which says, let every house be locked at a proper hour; let no groups of riotous men parade the streets in the silence of the night; let female virtue, the first source and best bond of society, be inviolably protected. Otherwise the guilty city and nation will forfeit its existence in the eyes of heaven. Thanks be to God, that this evil was confined to Benjamin, and was renounced with horror by all the assembled tribes.